Pittsburgh City Council will debate this week whether to hire a consultant to nominate Lawrenceville as a historic district with the National Register of Historic Places, the official federal list of “historic places worthy of preservation.”
The nomination is part of an effort to help locals maintain the character of a neighborhood drawing developers in droves, Councilwoman Deb Gross said.
“The change just keeps coming in this neighborhood and it’s more all the time,” said Ms. Gross, standing in her office last week before a map of her district dotted with red spots indicating dozens of development sites. “There’s a reason people love Lawrenceville.”
A National Register designation could be one means of mitigating some of that change, and Ms. Gross predicted a “fulsome discussion” among Lawrenceville’s various neighborhood groups on the merits of the plan.
The consultant would steer the community through an extensive process that would involve surveying every structure in the neighborhood to determine whether it would be a “contributing building” to the historic district. The estimated $75,000 cost would be paid through a state historical commission grant of $25,000, $25,000 from the city’s Urban Redevelopment Authority and $25,000 from the city’s 2014 Cultural Heritage Plan Community Development Block Grant.
The legislation is scheduled for discussion Wednesday by council’s Standing Committee.
Read More
Carol Peterson, an architectural and community historian and a member of the Lawrenceville Stakeholders nonprofit group, has pushed for years for a National Register designation for the neighborhood. The neighborhood is home to songwriter Stephen Foster’s birthplace and grave, the grounds of the Allegheny Arsenal and other historic sites.
“It deserves the honor of being listed,” she said, noting that the designation makes owners of income-producing historic structures eligible for tax credits for the rehabilitation of buildings, providing an incentive to restore rather than demolish. “It raises awareness that it’s not just a trendy neighborhood of the moment but it’s a neighborhood with a 201-year history.”
Neither of the neighborhood’s major community organizations, Lawrenceville United and the Lawrenceville Corp., have taken a position on the nomination, which must be made through the Pennsylvania Historical and Museum Commission.
“Right now we’re agnostic about it,” said Matthew Galluzzo, executive director of the Lawrenceville Corp. “The beauty of this is there’s a process built into it. There will be ample time for folks to wrap their heads around what this designation means.”
Lauren Byrne, executive director of Lawrenceville United, was singing from the same hymnal.
“We wouldn’t have a position until we’ve engaged residents and stakeholders and property owners around the issue,” she said. “City Planning has pledged to make sure that happens.”
Patrick Andrus, a National Register historian, said the register, maintained by the National Parks Service, receives about 1,200 nominations per year. They are weighed on a range of criteria, including whether the structure or district reflects the period for which it claims significance and architectural value, among others.
“For every building that is part of that district, a determination is made. Does it contribute? Does it date to that period of significance?” Mr. Andrus said.
A turn-of-the-century brick rowhouse, for instance, might count, but not the Wendy’s on Butler Street.
Placement on the register confers a degree of protection against demolition, but only in the case of projects or properties that receive federal dollars, he added.
Keith Heinrich, a historic preservation specialist with the Pennsylvania Historical and Museum Commission, said there are 29 designated historic districts in the city, ranging from Deutschtown and the Mexican War Streets to East Carson Street, parts of Downtown, Schenley Park, and Highland Park. If the commission’s board and staff agree on a historic designation for a neighborhood, the National Register generally accepts the nomination, he added.
Robert Zullo: rzullo@post-gazette.com, 412-263-3909 or on Twitter @rczullo.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.