The public should get a cut of the sale of the Penguins if the deal includes development rights to the 28-acre former Civic Arena site, Mayor Bill Peduto said Friday.

The mayor confirmed that city, county, Sports Exhibition Authority and Urban Redevelopment Authority lawyers are negotiating with the Penguins to ensure that return on the significant public investment will be rewarded when a sale is finalized, if it includes ongoing Hill District redevelopment.

Mr. Peduto characterized the talks as “a friendly conversation” at this point.

“We know that we have an agreement to develop the public land, and if they’re going to sell that to make a profit, then the public should also be a part of that deal,” Mr. Peduto said. “We want to make sure that as we continue with the partnership, that it is addressed clearly. There’s been a lot of money, public money, that’s gone into that site. Much more than they’ve [Penguins] put in — exponentially more. That cannot just be monetized for individual profit.”

Advertise with us

In early June, Penguins majority owners Mario Lemieux and Ron Burkle announced they were exploring a sale of the franchise. The asking price: $750 million.

It has been unclear, however, whether the club’s exclusive development rights to the former Civic Arena site will be part of the deal.

Mr. Peduto said the city doesn’t know the answer to that, and it’s likely the Penguins don’t know either.

“I think the Penguins are still deciding that, probably waiting for bids to come in to determine it,” he said.

Forbes valued the team at $565 million in November.

Advertise with us

Mr. Lemieux and Mr. Burkle bought the franchise out of bankruptcy in 1999, then obtained development rights to the arena site in 2007 as part of a deal to build Consol Energy Center and keep the team in Pittsburgh.

Significant amounts of public money, including $15 million a year in state funding and casino dollars, helped build the rink. Millions more has and will go toward basic infrastructure like roads and utilities for ongoing Hill District development.

But does the public have any right to a cut if only the team is sold?

“If it's just the team, they would be correct. The team itself is owned by Lemieux and Burkle and operates separately from the organization that operates the development rights,” Mr. Peduto said.

“The development rights utilize publicly owned land by the SEA and URA. We have to identify the terms to be able to move forward, and certainly so would” any prospective owner.

Advertise with us

Mr. Peduto said he believes the city has leverage.

“I think the leverage lies in the amount of public money that has been invested in this site,” he said. “It really doesn’t make sense to monetize it for the benefit of a very few and not have the public benefit as well.”

A request to speak with David Morehouse, Penguins president and CEO, was denied Friday through a team spokesman.

Former State Sen. Jim Ferlo, a member of the Urban Redevelopment Authority board, said he raised the issue last month at a URA board meeting.

“I was making the point that I was a concerned that there might be a potential sale of the franchise and potentially the acreage” Mr. Ferlo said.

Advertise with us

“It was looking like a bidding war for $600 million, or $700-plus. I was making an argument that morally and legally we should get a return on that investment. If they make $750 million, there should be a 10 percent contribution back.”

Mr. Ferlo said the partnership with the Penguins has been an amicable one, and he will push for an agreement that keeps the public in mind.

“Everybody knows Mario is a class act, no question,” Mr. Ferlo said. “But this is not about any of that. This is about public tax dollars subsidizing the franchise. If I’m going to be asked as a URA board voting member to sign off on a deal that involves [the acreage] I’m not voting for any deal unless it’s clear we get a return on our investment.”

City officials told the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette last week that the SEA and URA would have to sign off on a deal that includes the development rights.

Jenn Menendez: jmenendez@post-gazette.com or on Twitter @JennMenendez. Rich Lord: rlord@post-gazette.com, 412-263-1542 or on Twitter @richelord.