The Pittsburgh Intergovernmental Cooperation Authority, which has been feuding with Mayor Bill Peduto’s administration for months over the authority’s withholding of millions in state gaming revenue, denied the vast majority of a sprawling city records request for emails, contracts, receipts, invoices, bank statements and other materials.

ICA Chairman Nicholas Varischetti said in a statement that the authority, governed by a board of political appointees and one of two financial oversight entities for Pittsburgh, is “fully committed to meeting both the letter and spirit of Pennsylvania's Right to Know Law” as well as to the “open and transparent operation of this oversight panel.”

However, the authority denied outright 20 of 27 enumerated requests in a letter sent last month by city Finance Director Paul Leger, who also is a nonvoting member of the ICA board. The authority granted just one request in its entirety: all of its budgets between 2005 and 2015, its entire period of existence. Another six requests were granted in part and denied in part.

“Where necessary we have denied Mr. Leger's request, in accordance with state law, because his request was insufficiently specific, vague, overbroad and/​or requires the ICA to compile information in a manner not already done by the ICA,” Mr. Varischetti wrote.

Advertise with us

In addition to the records request, the city is suing the authority in Allegheny County Common Pleas Court to compel it to release nearly $13 million of the city’s share of state casino revenue from the past two years. By the end of December, that figure will rise to $20 million. Mr. Peduto’s administration also has asked the state Department of Community and Economic Development to dissolve the authority, which was created in 2004 by the state Legislature and was supposed to cease to exist after the city had “annual operating budgets and five-year financial plans approved by the board for at least the three immediately preceding years.”

A review of the city’s request by the Department of Community and Economic Development’s legal team is still ongoing, a department spokeswoman said this week.

The ICA has asserted its discretion to withhold the money until the city finishes the installation of a long-awaited payroll component of a financial management system that Mr. Peduto’s administration, when it took office in 2014, put on hold because of concerns over cost overruns and mismanagement. The payroll module will be finished by the end of the year or sooner, Mr. Peduto's office has said.

The authority also has filed objections to the city’s suit and seeks to have it dismissed or moved to Commonwealth Court.

“We continue to ask the mayor to meet with this board directly to resolve these issues. Instead of wasting taxpayer resources responding to the mayor's frivolous lawsuits, we should be having a conversation for the benefit of Pittsburgh. It is impossible to have a productive relationship with the mayor while he has a gun pointed at the ICA's head,” Mr. Varischetti wrote.

Advertise with us

The authority says it has authorized the release of about $4.1 million in gaming revenue to date but hasn’t transferred it to the city because the city “has yet to submit the required documentation to enable the transfer of these funds.”

That figure includes $2.5 million approved at the ICA's June meeting for renovation of city buildings and a cyber security program. The city has not submitted “any documentation necessary to access these funds,” the ICA says.

Mr. Peduto’s administration, which has accused the authority of habitually overstepping its bounds and “usurping” the city’s right to direct its own financial affairs, also has argued that the ICA already approved the distribution of the gaming money when it approved the city’s 2015 budget and the line items that depend on that revenue.

Tim McNulty, a spokesman for Mr. Peduto, said the city is reviewing the ICA's response. It was unclear whether the city will appeal the denial to the state's Open Records Office.

“It is sad, but unfortunately no surprise, that the ICA refuses to fully document its stewardship of millions of dollars in taxpayer money,” Mr. McNulty said in an email. “This confirms why the city was forced to go to court in the first place. City residents deserve real answers on what the ICA has been doing with the money due to them under state law.”

Robert Zullo: rzullo@post-gazette.com or 412-263-3909. Twitter: @rczullo.