Paul Sciullo became a police officer to make a difference.
While the Duquesne University graduate had a degree in psychology, the Sept. 11, 2001, terrorist attacks inspired him to pursue a career in law enforcement instead.
“He always had this uneasiness where he didn’t feel he was making a difference,” his mother, Sue Sciullo, said. “He was always happy and really had a nice life, but when he became a police officer I had never seen him happier in all my life. He felt like he was doing something for the community.”
He entered the Pittsburgh police academy and had been on the force for two years when he and two other officers, Eric Kelly and Stephen Mayhle, received a domestic call from a mother requesting her son be removed from her home.
Police say on that day — April 4, 2009 — Richard Poplawski armed himself with an AK-47 assault-style rifle and a bulletproof vest and ambushed the officers as they responded to his mother’s Stanton Heights house, killing all three.
Poplawski was sentenced to death. He is one of nine inmates on death row from Allegheny County.
In February, Gov. Tom Wolf issued a moratorium on executions, saying death penalties were “based on a flawed system that has been proven to be an endless cycle of court proceedings as well as ineffective, unjust and expensive.” Mr. Wolf said the decision will stand until a bipartisan commission, formed in 2011, completes its review on the effectiveness of capital punishment in Pennsylvania.
Less than a month after Mr. Wolf issued the moratorium, Ms. Sciullo of Bloomfield wrote a letter to the governor about her son and his fellow slain officers.
“[Poplawski] was given a fair trial by an exceptional jury who passed the sentence on him and he was found guilty,” she said. “The evidence was overwhelming. I don't know how anybody could put a stop to this man being put to death.”
She said she has not received a response, nor did she expect one.
“I just wanted him to know how we felt,” she said. “Nobody understands how deep this pain goes until you’ve lived it. It’s there when you go to bed, there when you wake up in the middle of the night and there again in the morning to be with you all day.”
Mr. Wolf cited statistics that show more than 150 people nationwide have been exonerated from death row, including six in Pennsylvania. The most recent execution in Pennsylvania was in 1999. The state has only executed three people since capital punishment was reinstated in the 1970s.
“This decision is absolutely in no way an expression of sympathy for those on death row,” Mr. Wolf’s spokesman Jeffrey Sheridan said this week. “There are some people there found guilty of heinous crimes. He has the utmost sympathy of the families of victims.”
State Sen. Stewart Greenleaf, R-Montgomery, heads the task force on the death penalty. His counsel, Patrick Cawley, said this week that the review has taken “longer than anyone expected” mostly due to data collection from various counties throughout the state. However, he expects the investigation to be completed by spring 2016.
Support and opposition to the moratorium has poured in from all sides.
Various civil rights groups statewide, including the Pennsylvania NAACP, Philadelphia Bar Association, Jewish Social Policy Action Network, Pennsylvanians Against the Death Penalty and the American Civil Liberties Union have supported of the measure. The organizations filed a friend-of-the-court brief in June, citing “pervasive failures” in the system, including high reversal rates of conviction, racial bias and under-funded representation for low-income defendants
The Pennsylvania District Attorneys Association, however, said the moratorium violates parts of the state constitution and could affect plea bargains and the way judges and juries view executions. State Attorney General Kathleen Kane also spoke out against the measure, asking the state Supreme Court to declare unconstitutional the reprieves Mr. Wolf granted pending the study’s conclusion.
Mike Manko, spokesman for Allegheny County District Attorney Stephen A. Zappala Jr. said his office will continue to file capital punishment cases “when appropriate.”
“The governor’s stance did not change the law of the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania,” Mr. Manko said.
In June, the Republican-controlled House approved a resolution stating the moratorium “exhibits an astounding disregard for the additional and unnecessary heartache” of families of death row inmates' victims.
Ms. Sciullo said she does not know if Poplawski will be executed in her lifetime, or at all.
“He put a death sentence on Paul, Eric and Steven,” she said. “His should stand.”






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.