A landlord under fire for telling some residents of two East Liberty apartment buildings that they had 90 days to leave to make way for redevelopment of the site has agreed to rescind those notices and put a stay on issuing any more.

That agreement between the city of Pittsburgh and owners of Penn Plaza Apartments was reached just hours after a heated and emotional meeting Saturday morning between about 200 tenants and city and county leaders.

“We’ve agreed to the 60-day stay and we’re hopeful we can come to a broader agreement” on the issues surrounding redevelopment of the site, Jonathan Kamin, attorney for the owners, said in an interview after the meeting. He did not attend the meeting but was negotiating with city officials by phone much of the day Saturday.

Pennley Park South Inc., the corporation that owns the buildings, is owned by the Gumberg family. The family owns LG Realty, which manages Penn Plaza.

Advertise with us

Pittsburgh Mayor Bill Peduto told tenants Saturday that in meetings since the city first found out about the 90-day notices that went out 10 days ago, city officials told the Gumbergs the city wanted them to rescind the notices, to include some affordable housing in their plans for the site and to create a fund that would provide financial assistance to help residents move.

Moreover, the mayor told the tenants: “We’ve got to make sure this is the stand that is taken so other developers in the city know this is not how we do business in the city” by abruptly kicking poorer residents out of a building to make way for wealthier tenants, without offering them help.

The broader discussions of the development itself will also include trying to figure out how to “phase in” the development and prevent anyone from being displaced without a new, affordable home in the neighborhood, said Kevin Acklin, Mr. Peduto’s chief of staff.

It was Mr. Acklin who negotiated with Mr. Kamin on the 60-day stay agreement, a process that was ongoing even as Saturday morning’s meeting was taking place.

Mr. Peduto, city Councilman Ricky Burgess, state Rep. Ed Gainey, D-Lincoln-Lemington, and county Executive Rich Fitzgerald met for about 90 minutes Saturday morning in the East Liberty Lutheran Church.

Advertise with us

The church is located across Penn Avenue from the two, red brick Penn Plaza apartment buildings which were opened in 1968 by the late developer Pat Navarro Sr. using about $5 million in Federal Housing Authority low-interest loans. Sometime later the Gumbergs bought the site.

The original federal loans, authorized in 1964, came with covenants that prevented redevelopment of the site for 40 years. The covenants expired in 2004, freeing the way for the Gumbergs to redevelop the site, Mr. Kamin said.

About six years later the Gumbergs began preparing for redevelopment by not renewing annual leases, he said, and instead went to month-to-month leases. At the same time they also stopped leasing out about 70 of the apartments that needed renovation.

With about 230 apartments still being leased out of about 320 total, there are still more than 500 people, according to tenants, many of them working class, poor and elderly who are concerned that they won’t be able to find affordable replacement housing anywhere near their current homes.

Efficiency apartments at Penn Plaza rent for about $470 a month, residents say, and two-bedroom apartments go for about $850. That’s less than the $1,200-and-up rental rates on the new apartments that many residents have found opening in the neighborhood.

Advertise with us

“I’m a working person but I could never afford $1,300 a month,” said Pamela Robinson, 51, a security guard for Pittsburgh Public Schools who has lived at Penn Plaza for seven years. “That would be about one-third of my salary.”

Mr. Kamin said that the company “recognizes that the affordable housing issue is a citywide problem and we believe that developers should take the lead in addressing the issue.”

Mr. Peduto and other community leaders asked residents of the building to form a tenant council so that a few representatives could be at the table to negotiate in future meetings with the city and the Gumbergs.

“We need to be part of this process so that the owners know that what they’ve done is unjust,” said resident Gail Williams, 66, a retired UPMC housekeeper who has lived in Penn Plaza for three years and worries she’ll have to move out of the neighborhood.

Mr. Peduto said he hopes no one will have to move out of the neighborhood if they don’t want to and the city intends to use all of its leverage to prod the Gumbergs to help prevent that.

Advertise with us

The company has told city officials it is considering a mixed-use development combining both residential and retail on the 7-acre site that surrounds a 2-acre, city-owned park, Enright Parklet, in between the two buildings.

That city-owned park may be small, but it could have a big impact on how the site is developed, Mr. Peduto said.

In addition to zoning and possible government financial support for the development, the park “is our leverage,” he said. “If they tried to develop it without [the park] they'd have a doughnut.”

Sean D. Hamill: shamill@post-gazette.com or 412-263-2579