The Carnegie Museums of Pittsburgh is looking for a new contractor for its restaurants after ending a long-standing relationship with the food service arm of Eat’n Park Hospitality Group.

At a time when museums around the country are amping up their restaurants by bringing in big-name chefs and seeking more diverse culinary offerings, the Carnegie has decided to end its relationship of 19 years with Parkhurst Dining.

Betsy Momich, spokeswoman for the Carnegie Museums of Pittsburgh, confirmed that the museums’ contract with Parkhurst will not be renewed and that a new food service provider will be determined in the next few weeks.

She had no comment as to why the museums have decided to seek out a new food service provider.

Advertise with us

“The Carnegie Museums was one of our first accounts,” said Kevin O’Connell, senior vice president of marketing for Eat’n Park Hospitality Group.

Parkhurst was founded in 1996 and has since grown to manage food service for 50 primarily corporate, hospital and university accounts in nine states, including food service for Duquesne University in the Bluff neighborhood and Google headquarters in Larimer.

“We have had a terrific relationship,” he said. “And we respect that the Carnegie Museums are deciding to go in a different direction.”

In addition to overseeing museum events and catering, Parkhurst ran the Museum of Art Cafe and the Fossil Fuels Cafe in the Carnegie museums of art and natural history in Oakland. It also ran the River View Cafe at the Carnegie Science Center and the Warhol Cafe in the Andy Warhol Museum, both on the North Shore (except for nearly a decade in the early 2000s in which the Big Burrito Restaurant Group managed the Warhol accounts).

As early as February, Jo Ellen Parker, president and CEO of the Carnegie Museums, had organized a dining task force to consider alternatives. And a dining consultant reviewed at least the cafe and catering service at the Carnegie Museum of Art.

Advertise with us

“The nature of the food service needs to be changed,” Lynn Zelevansky, director of the Carnegie Museum of Art since 2009, told the Post-Gazette. “There would be no cafeteria line or busing your own plates. That would be my preference.”

The dining consultant’s opinion “was that there was more money to be made,” Ms. Zelevansky said.

The split comes as Suzanne “Suzy” Broadhurst remains a member of the board of trustees for the Carnegie Museums of Pittsburgh as well as on the board for the Carnegie Science Center. She is also chair of the fundraising campaign for the Carnegie Science Center.

Ms. Broadhurst’s husband, Jim Broadhurst, is chairman of Eat’n Park Hospitality Group; she had been the director of corporate giving until 2011. Their sons hold leadership roles in the company, with Jeff Broadhurst the president and CEO; Brooks Broadhurst the senior vice president of food and beverage; and Mark Broadhurst the vice president of corporate dining and retail development.

Two years ago, the food service operations for Eat’n Park Hospitality Group began pulling in more revenue than the company’s more than 70 restaurants. Company revenues were $403 million in 2013 and $355 million the previous year.

Advertise with us

In addition to her positions on the boards, Ms. Broadhurst ran the Carnegie Museums on an interim basis, when Ellsworth Brown left in 2004 until 2005, when David Hillenbrand became president. John Wetenhall was his successor in 2011, but left after 17 months. Mr. Hillenbrand ran the museum complex in an interim capacity until Ms. Parker was appointed his successor as president and CEO of the Carnegie Museums of Pittsburgh in August.

Several catering companies and restaurant groups have been approached to run dining and food service for the Carnegie Museums, including Big Burrito, which did not submit a proposal. Big Burrito ran the Warhol Cafe for nearly 10 years as well as Cafe Phipps at the Phipps Conservatory and Botanical Gardens for three years in the early 2000s.

At least three food service and hospitality groups have submitted proposals, including Culinaire Distinctive Dining & Hospitality Management based in Dallas, which was confirmed by that company’s spokesperson.

Culinaire is the company behind several restaurants, from chains such as Shula’s America’s Steak House with locations in eight states, to a chef-driven hotel restaurant in Washington, D.C., Todd Gray’s Watershed Coastal Cuisine in the Hilton Garden Inn. Mr. Gray is a five-time James Beard nominee for “Best Chef: mid-Atlantic” for his restaurant, Equinox, also in Washington.

Once the Carnegie Museums decides on a food service provider, there may be room for restructuring that could include a similar chef-driven restaurant.

Advertise with us

At least one chef has been approached by museum leadership as well as multiple food service companies that have submitted proposals.

Sonja Finn, chef/​owner of Dinette in East Liberty, has confirmed that she has been approached by Culinaire and two other food service groups as potentially collaborating with the museums in some capacity, which could mean her name is attached to a restaurant at one or more of the museums, for which she would design the concept with the museums’ guidance, structure the menu and provide key staff.

Ms. Finn has been nominated as a James Beard semifinalist for “Rising Star Chef of the Year,” in 2009 and 2010.

“If this happens,” she said, “it would be a dream come true.”

Melissa McCart: 412-263-1198 or on Twitter @melissamccart.