The former director of a Lawrenceville community bank whose theft scheme helped drive the institution out of business after more than 100 years of service was sentenced Friday to 12 years in federal prison.

U.S. District Judge Arthur Schwab imposed that term on Michael Bernick, 51, who ran Metropolitan Savings Bank and systematically fleeced it by taking out loans that few knew about and that he did not repay.

He was convicted of stealing $347,000 but the judge imposed a restitution order of about $9.9 million, which represents the total losses to the FDIC and the bank’s 23 uninsured depositors. Prosecutors said Bernick’s conduct contributed to the failure of the bank in 2007 and asked that his punishment include the institution’s demise.

One of the affected depositors, Allan Becer, who served in the Army during the Vietnam War, addressed the court in saying Bernick’s thefts cost him more than $57,000, money he had saved over the years and relied on after he became disabled and lost his job.

Advertise with us

“This was money I was counting on,” he said. “There are times when I get very, very angry about this.”

He said the bank, which served Lawrenceville’s blue-collar community since 1892, had been run by directors everyone in the neighborhood knew and trusted until a new breed he called “wolves in sheeps’ clothing” moved in. He said Bernick, a contractor who bought and renovated dilapidated properties in the city, was among them and stole from everyone. Prosecutors said he used Metropolitan’s money to pay off debts when his properties went into foreclosure.

Bernick told the judge that he took over a rundown bank and fixed it up to make it respectable again but did not express remorse or admit that he stole any money. He has long insisted he planned to repay the unauthorized loans he took out in 2005 and 2006.

Bernick was convicted by a jury in September on numerous counts related to fraud and embezzlement at the bank. His co-defendant, Donna Shebetich, 50, a bank officer with whom he was having an affair, is serving six years in prison after pleading guilty to helping him steal the money.

After the sentence was imposed, the U.S. attorney’s office asked that Bernick be required to report to prison immediately, in part because prosecutors said authorities had information that Bernick had been bragging in bars that he was planning to “take off.”

Advertise with us

The judge let him self-report in August, however, and ordered him to remain on home detention until then.

Correction (posted June 5, 2015): An earlier version of this story had an incorrect amount of money Michael Bernick was convicted of stealing.