Two years in the making, Market St. Grocery has been seeing brisk business since it opened late April as the first Downtown grocery in five years.

The market is building a selection of ingredients and products for the neighborhood's growing population of residents as well as commuters who work Downtown. Its goal is to provide local ingredients and unusual products as well as staples at competitive prices.

It's still a work in progress. "Some people come in here and don't get what we're trying to do," said executive chef Michael LaMantia.

Mr. LaMantia is an alum of Parkhurst Dining, a regional hospitality company owned by Eat'n Park and serves colleges, universities, corporations, museums and other cultural institutions. It's where he led the kitchens at PNC Firstside Cafeteria among others. Mr. LaMantia also helped set up Giant Eagle Market District in Bethel Park.

Advertise with us

Today, he is helping to create an ambitious independent market, the result of handiwork in terms of liquor licenses and stores-within-a-store from the partners: developer Ralph Falbo and his stepson, David Priselac; and the Vallozzis of Vallozzi's restaurants.

It includes a wine bar at the back of the grocery that is also a retail store featuring wines from the Collefrisio winery in Italy. Visitors can buy wine by the bottle or the case, or sip it by the glass at a table.

Pittsburgh History & Landmarks Foundation rehabilitated the market space, the site of the former Ciao Baby restaurant in the Thompson Building, which was built about 1928.

"We had to work with the city and historic preservation, which took more time in the construction," said Mr. Priselac. Developers had hoped to open the grocery a year ago.

Mr. LaMantia commented on the kitchen design in the lower level. "It was basically dirt down there," he said. When they started building out the space, however, they hit brick and cobblestone walkways, which had to be removed.

Advertise with us

The prepared foods have the most loyal customers so far, who visit for breakfast sandwiches, as well as lunchtime dishes such as baked ziti, crab cakes, salads and sandwiches.

But "groceries are a finicky thing," Mr. LaMantia said.

That means there's some trial and error, such as adjusting the offerings at the cheese counter, for example, from a high-end selection of award-winning cheeses to include pre-sliced offerings for sandwiches, too.

Shoppers may have also noticed occasionally empty meat and produce cases, the result of reorganizing the store and having to order custom cases more efficient for small spaces.

"We are not an industrial-sized scale," said Mr. LaMantia. "We have to use this to our advantage in terms of ordering and displaying quality products and supplies."

Advertise with us

The market also is gearing up to sell local produce, ordering from local distributor Penn's Corner Farm Alliance as well as the Chef's Garden from the Jones family, a well-regarded supplier for fine dining based in Huron, Ohio.

Here are a few standout products at Market St. Grocery:

La Colombe coffee

Founded in Philadelphia in 1994 with shops in New York, Chicago and Washington, D.C., La Colombe trained baristas here in brewing methods for each specialty coffee, including the robust Savoia ($12.99 for a 12-ounce bag) and the balanced Nizza ($11.99). Founded by discerning coffee drinkers who started their coffee resume back in 1985, Spokane, Wash.-native Todd Carmichael and Frenchman Jean Philippe Iberti have since trekked the world to source and roast beautiful coffees.

Weatherbury Farm grain products

Advertise with us

Weatherbury Farm from Avella packages 2-pound bags of polenta ($6.49), buckwheat flour ($7.99) and 1½-pound bags of rolled oats ($8.49), all certified organic. A grain farmer since 2009, Weatherbury Farm led by Nigel Tudor is one of the most progressive in the area when it comes to grains, where he's milling with an Austrian flour mill. It would be great if the market would also supply whole wheat and white flour, variations of which Mr. Tudor also sells at the farm.

Collefrisio Pecorino wine

Market Street Grocery

435 Market St.

Downtown

Advertise with us

10 a.m.-11 p.m. Mondays through Saturdays; 10 a.m.-10 p.m. Sundays.

412-281-3818

marketstreetgrocery.com

Collefrisio Pecorino ($14.99) is an enthralling white wine from Le Marche that's delightful for spring, with notes of grass and a little banana. Pecorino is a signature at this vineyard that has a connection to the market owners.

"They kind of found us," said Mr. Priselac about the vineyard. They liked the wine so much they decided to partner with them. In addition to a selection of Collefrisio wines by the glass and the bottle, the wine bar offers a menu that includes charcuterie from Trois Petits Cochons in New York along with olives and cheeses from the market.

Advertise with us

Three Rivers Grown dairy purveyor

Three Rivers Grown is a newish dairy distributor based in the Strip District, founded by Nathan Holmes and Abby Long. Every Tuesday, they're bringing in whole, 2 percent and chocolate milk ($3.99) from Brunton Dairy based in Independence, Beaver County. They also provide Pasture Maid cream from the New Castle-based dairy and eggs from pasture-raised chickens from Serenity Hill Farms in Cheswick.

Dairy not supplied from Three Rivers Grown includes cultured butter from Trickling Springs Creamery in Chambersburg and will soon carry Millie's Homemade Ice Cream from Pittsburgh natives Chad and Lauren Townsend, who are setting up their pasturizing facility in Homewood and will open in June.

Benedetto Cavalieri pasta

Made from durum semolina or whole wheat, this flavorful pasta from the Puglia region holds its shape and is among the most flavorful dried pastas around. Wine Spectator ranked it as a favorite.

Advertise with us

"We make our baked ziti with it," Mr. LaMantia said. "It's why the so many people love ours." Although it hadn't been on the shelves during my last visit, you will soon find bucatini, penne and orecchiette among others.

Local meats from Elysian Fields, Jubilee Hilltop Ranch, Logan Family Farms, Clarion River Organic and Burns Heritage Farm

As much as possible, whole animals are delivered to the market that the kitchen staff butchers to order or for display, allowing the market to keep prices competitive.

Meats include lamb from Elysian Fields Farm in Waynesburg, where farmer Keith Martin practices what he calls holistic animal-raising, where he treats lambs humanely and feeds them only grain and hay. The result is a very tender, flavorful lamb ($17.99 pound rack of lamb or bone-in chop).

Customers will also find grass-fed beef as well as eggs from Jubilee Hilltop Ranch in Osterburg ($15.99 pound hanger steak; $11.90 pound 80/20 ground beef; $18.99 pound rib eye); dry-aged beef from Irwin-based Logan Family Farms; pork from Clarion River Organic in Sligo and never-frozen chicken from Ridgway-based Burns Heritage Farm.

Advertise with us

Schaller & Weber sausages

Founded in Manhattan in the 1920s, this European-style meat emporium remains a family-run business that makes and distributes knackwurst, Hungarian kolbase, Polish kielbasa, bratwurst and frankfurters. If you're looking for a special order, ask.

Castillo de Canena olive oil

Made in the Andalusian province of Jaén in Spain, the Vano family produces one of the 20-highest-ranked olive oils in the world. Market St. Grocery offers the 2014 crop from fruity arbequina as well as full-bodied picual olives ($27.89-$28.19).

Gaby et Jules canales

Advertise with us

Squirrel Hill-based Gaby et Jules has opened its second location here, and it's one of the few pastry shops that makes this French treat, a specialty of the Bordeaux region ($2.80 a piece; six for $14.50). No, it's not burnt; that's caramelization on the outside and dark is good. Inside, it's light and custard-like.

Can't find what you're looking for?

"Be patient with us," Mr. LaMantia said of the grocery's progress. "We often have things in the back or downstairs and if we don't we can get it in 24 hours."

Melissa McCart: 412-263-1198 or on Twitter @melissamccart

Correction, posted May 28, 2015: Parkhurst Dining is a regional hospitality company owned by Eat'n Park. An earlier version contained incorrect information.