Pittsburgh Mayor Bill Peduto isn’t up for re-election until 2017. His ally, Allegheny County Executive Rich Fitzgerald, is running unopposed.

Yet both men were arguably among the losers in Tuesday’s Democratic primary, as they proved to have coattails shorter than those on Mr. Peduto’s once-famous puffy vest.

“You have a number of people who weren’t supported by the powers on Grant Street but were successful despite that — and in some cases because of it,” said Pittsburgh Controller Michael Lamb.

Using their own political committees and other entities, Mr. Peduto and Mr. Fitzgerald backed Mr. Lamb’s challenger, Councilwoman Natalia Rudiak, as well as candidates for city and county council.

Advertise with us

Yet, according to unofficial vote tallies, Ms. Rudiak lost by 2-to-1 margins citywide. The men’s legislative candidates also fared poorly, and in the high-profile race for Allegheny County controller Mr. Fitzgerald’s champion — Mark Patrick Flaherty — lost to incumbent Chelsa Wagner.

So … what happened?

In general, the latest leaders are following a tradition of short coattails that began with the late Mayor Pete Flaherty’s run against the machine in the 1970s. Incumbents are rarely ousted, but it’s also uncommon for them to build their base by pulling their preferred candidates into office with them.

Pittsburgh-area voters are willing to set someone up as a potential leader, but then they take steps to control their power.

Prior to election day, Mr. Peduto characterized the contests as battles among reformers and “the same people who supported Luke Ravenstahl,” Pittsburgh’s former mayor and Mr. Peduto’s longtime foe. Indeed, Mr. Lamb, Ms. Wagner and Councilwoman Darlene Harris — another Peduto target — drew financial backing from Ravenstahl allies like former state Sen. Jim Ferlo and businessman John Verbanac, who each gave money to two of the three.

Advertise with us

Mr. Ravenstahl’s own political committee gave $1,000 to county council hopeful Denise Ranalli Russell, who narrowly leads Mr. Fitzgerald’s preferred candidate.

But Mr. Peduto’s and Mr. Fitzgerald’s efforts also put them at odds with their own political and geographic base: East End voters who’ve previously opposed Mr. Ravenstahl. Ms. Wagner won the city’s liberal 14th Ward by a whopping 3-to-1 margin. Mr. Lamb also performed well there.

“I think the 14th Ward wants a level playing field,” said Squirrel Hill attorney Sam Hens-Greco, an active player in neighborhood politics. “We’re a one-party town, so we need people willing to stand up. I think people here respect that dynamic. How many years did Bill Peduto do that with Mayor Ravenstahl?”

Mike Mikus, a political consultant who worked for Mr. Fitzgerald’s allies, said that while voters broadly support Mr. Fitzgerald, they “want a controller to be independent. They saw two qualified people running for county controller, and 52 percent saw Chelsa as someone they thought was both qualified and independent.”

A similar dynamic shaped Ms. Rudiak’s race, he surmised.

Advertise with us

Mr. Peduto and Mr. Fitzgerald aren’t the region’s first would-be kingmakers to meet with such a rebuke.

Former Mayor Tom Murphy, for one, could often do little to help allies, even as he completed an ambitious development and policy agenda during three terms as mayor. Among his setbacks: Barbara Burns, a close council ally from Mr. Murphy’s own North Side base, lost a 2003 re-election bid to Mr. Ravenstahl, at the time a 23-year-old upstart.

“I have no confidence in coattails,” said Mr. Murphy, today a senior resident fellow at the Urban Land Institute. “I think you inherit people’s adversaries, and not their friends.”

Not everyone agrees. “When guys in power give people a good reason [for backing a candidate], people go along,” said political consultant Don Friedman, who worked with Ms. Wagner’s campaign and another of Ms. Harris’ opponents, Randy Zotter. “But when it seems personal and petty, voters see it for what it is.”

Mr. Peduto also may be hurt by the kind of good-government overhauls he favors, said Moe Coleman, a University of Pittsburgh professor emeritus who once worked for 1960s-era Mayor Joseph Barr.

Advertise with us

“Back then, with the power of patronage, it was hard to go against party leaders,” Mr. Coleman recalled. But civil-service overhauls and other changes have taken such leverage away.

“Government reform is fine,” Mr. Coleman added. “But you lose some control.”

Chris Potter: cpotter@post-gazette.com or 412-263-2533.