This spring, Pittsburgh Mayor Bill Peduto’s campaign contributed $8,000 to city Councilwoman Natalia Rudiak in her race for city controller. Under a 2009 city campaign-finance ordinance that Mr. Peduto championed, that’s the most his campaign can give to a citywide candidate in an election cycle.

But that contribution was only the beginning of his generosity — and that of his ally, Allegheny County Executive Rich Fitzgerald. A wrinkle in the ordinance allows donors to avoid contribution limits by giving money to committees that pass it on to their candidates.

In mid-April, Mr. Peduto gave $7,000 to a 1-year-old political committee, the Pittsburgh-based Democratic Leadership PAC. Mr. Fitzgerald, whose campaign also gave Ms. Rudiak $8,000 directly, gave Democratic Leadership $25,000. Those contributions made up the vast majority of Democratic Leadership’s support, campaign-finance records show. And on April 13, Democratic Leadership gave $4,000 to Ms. Rudiak.

Two weeks later, Democratic Leadership contributed $4,000 to yet another committee, Progress Pittsburgh. Progress Pittsburgh sent a check for the same amount to Ms. Rudiak’s campaign the next day, its finance records show.

Advertise with us

The pattern angered city Controller Michael Lamb, whom Ms. Rudiak is challenging.

“I have serious questions about the legality of the contributions to Councilwoman Rudiak from county Executive Fitzgerald and Mayor Peduto, but there is no question about the hypocrisy of it,” he said. “They like to say it’s a new day in Pittsburgh. Seems like they go about it the old way.”

Ms. Rudiak’s campaign, which has raised more than $114,000 overall, declined to comment on the contributions.

Mr. Peduto said, “I can understand where some would question” this year’s contribution patterns. But he noted that during the 2013 mayoral race, then-Mayor Luke Ravenstahl contributed $261,000 to the Committee for a Better Pittsburgh, which aired TV ads attacking Mr. Peduto.

“I could do the same thing Luke did and create my own PAC,” Mr. Peduto said. Instead, he said, he was contributing only a fraction of that amount through established committees.

Advertise with us

The treasurer of Democratic Leadership is Matt Merriman-Preston, Mr. Peduto’s longtime political strategist and a consultant for Ms. Rudiak this year. His firm, Ampersand Consulting, is Democratic Leadership’s only other 2015 contributor, having contributed $5,100 to it while receiving $7,570.40 from it for “research” and other services.

But Mr. Merriman-Preston said it was not fair to view contributions to Democratic Leadership as “pass-throughs” — donations funneled through committees to skirt contribution limits.

“A pass-through would be if money was given with a direction to ‘put this much here and this much there,’ ” Mr. Merriman-Preston said. Neither Mr. Peduto nor Mr. Fitzgerald gave him such instructions, he said, though he allowed that “we have the same priorities.”

Mr. Merriman-Preston also noted that Progress Pittsburgh was established in 2007 and has long backed Mr. Peduto’s allies. The group had only $82.33 at the beginning of the year and Mr. Merriman-Preston chairs the group’s board, though he said he abstained from its vote last month to endorse Ms. Rudiak.

Mr. Merriman-Preston said he established Democratic Leadership last year. In 2014, it supported a handful of left-leaning groups and candidates outside Pittsburgh, using money contributed almost entirely by Ampersand. It had $1,239.71 left over before this year’s contributions. Still, Mr. Merriman-Preston said, “It’s not as if all of the sudden there were 12 new committees created to make contributions.”

Advertise with us

Even if there were, it’s not clear what could be done about it. Pittsburgh’s campaign-finance ordinance caps “political contributions to a candidate” but says nothing about contributions coming through separate committees.

Philadelphia’s campaign-finance ordinance, by contrast, limits contributions “including [those] made through one or more political committees.” J. Shane Creamer, who heads Philadelphia’s ethics board, said that provision was a response to a surge in “baby committees” being used to multiply the contributions a donor could make.

“We saw a loophole years ago, and we fixed it,” he said.

Pittsburgh’s ordinance has not been amended despite problematic provisions, including one that suspended contribution limits entirely for the 2013 mayoral race. Among other problems, while the law envisions regular hikes in the contribution limits, it doesn’t include a mechanism for establishing new values. As a result, the 2009 limits have remained.

As the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette reported Saturday, Mr. Peduto and Mr. Fitzgerald have also contributed $25,000 each to Better Jobs, Better Future. Though mostly active in county races, Better Jobs has given Ms. Rudiak $4,000 this year, finance records show.

Advertise with us

Mr. Peduto said he and his allies are facing a strong group of special interests who don’t support his agenda.

“We’re really bringing a knife to a gun fight,” Mr. Peduto said.

Chris Potter: cpotter@post-gazette.com or 412-263-2533.