A $1.6 million settlement agreement between the city of Pittsburgh and five rejected police candidates, announced Thursday, aims to remedy a hiring system that allegedly shunned blacks with tarnished backgrounds, while winking and nodding at blemished whites.
In recent years, the city offered jobs to scores of white candidates whose backgrounds included evidence of drug use, plus one who’d had sex with a minor and another who solicited a prostitute, according to records reviewed by the local American Civil Liberties Union.
During that same period, the city disqualified one black candidate who had a conviction for a summary disorderly conduct and another who the city said had a “bad driving record” and failed to respond to citations, according to the tentatively settled lawsuit.
Mayor Bill Peduto called the settlement “historic” Thursday and said the lawsuit “required a hard look in the mirror, and will take time and patience to achieve, but in the end we will have a qualified, competent and diverse police force that our neighborhoods and officers are even more proud of.”
The city wouldn’t confirm that racial discrimination occurred, a notion that worries some in the community.
“When you begin with the idea of minimizing [the problem], I get nervous,” said the Rev. DeNeice Welch, who previously sat on one of the panels that evaluated candidates, adding that she was “cautiously optimistic.”
Read More
The settlement, which must be approved by city council and a federal judge, calls for payments — totaling about $985,000 — to black police officer candidates who did not receive employment offers between 2008 and 2014. Five named plaintiffs will get as much as $20,000 each, with around 350 other rejected, African-American candidates getting — at minimum — $1,000 each.
Attorneys with the ACLU and Feinstein Doyle Payne & Kravec could get as much as $600,000 for time and expenses.
The 20-page settlement agreement gives the city a year to overhaul its police hiring process to “remedy” bias, and to use “rating scales” based on the desired characteristics of police officers. The city has 18 months to begin tracking the results.
The police bureau is now 85 percent white, 13 percent black, and just 1 percent each Asian and Hispanic. The last class hired by the city, in February, included 36 new officers, 32 of whom were white. The next application deadline is Monday.
Allegations that Pittsburgh has been using discriminatory hiring practices are not new.
When retired Detective Brenda Tate joined the force in 1979, the city was subject to a system, born of a lawsuit, under which it hired in groups of four — one black man, one black woman, one white man and one white woman.
A federal judge struck down the quota system in 1991 after a group of white officers argued the process was discriminatory.
Over the years, the ACLU said, racially skewed hiring crept back in the system. Although about 20 percent of applicants from 2001 through 2013 were African-American, just 4 percent of officers hired by the city were black.
The ACLU filed the latest suit in 2012. It went to a mediation process and the city and plaintiffs attorneys agreed to hire Minnesota-based consultant Leaetta Hough, who specializes in industrial and organizational psychology, to evaluate the city’s entry-level hiring practice. They split the cost of around $57,000, and the city has budgeted $250,000 to pay Ms. Hough and another consultant to help craft overhauls.
The city and ACLU didn’t necessarily agree on how to interpret Ms. Hough’s findings.
Witold Walczak, legal director of the ACLU of Pennsylvania, said that every step in the hiring process was “weeding out of African-American applicants.”
City solicitor Lourdes Sanchez-Ridge, on the other hand, said that “individually, no one part of the process had an adverse impact” on black candidates, but rather that the disadvantage occurred when the process was analyzed as a whole.
Ms. Hough’s report, reviewed by the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette, found that a written test overemphasized some qualities not ranked crucial to the job and underemphasized some other important ones — such as integrity.
Examiners who conducted oral exams sometimes violated their own rules. Some examiners did not recuse themselves when they knew an applicant, showed favoritism or evaluated characteristics that were not supposed to be considered, such as whether an applicant made eye contact, according to her report.
Ms. Tate recalled an instance when she sat on an oral examination panel and saw a supervisor pull a specific candidate’s file, then tell panel members they should “see [that candidate] through” the process to the next level.
“That right there was intimidating because you have to work with these people,” Ms. Tate said.
Ms. Tate said she felt the process unfairly favored white candidates, including some with relatives on the force.
Ms. Hough’s report took issue with the background screens that were conducted by the city’s Office of Municipal Investigations and presented to a group of police supervisors for evaluation.
After a judge’s order, the ACLU received hundreds of background files, typically hundreds of pages long, both for white candidates who received job offers between 2008 and 2014 and for black candidates who did not receive offers. Of those who received conditional offers, it’s unclear how many later went on to become city police officers.
“There seemed to be more intensive scrutiny of African-American applicants” with minor infractions prominently featured in background summaries, Mr. Walczak said. Arrests of white candidates didn’t always make it into the summaries, he said.
“There’s a recognition that a lot of people do dumb things, especially when they’re young,” he said. “It doesn’t mean that it automatically disqualifies them from being a good police officer.”
Draft of settlement agreement between city of Pittsburgh and ACLU



Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.