After a noisy confrontation involving a rival candidate and an audience member at an election forum last week, Pittsburgh Councilman Ricky V. Burgess said he will avoid further debates in the race for the Democratic nomination in his council district.

In letters sent to the sponsors of three planned primary debates, the incumbent recounted the events at the forum Thursday hosted by the African-Americans for Good Government in which one of his challengers, businesswoman Judith K. Ginyard, left the stage in response to a loud argument in the audience.

Mr. Burgess said he would not attend future events because “I now do not have the confidence that the candidate can behave in civil and appropriate manner at public events.”

The letter does not mention any names, but it is clear that he was referring to Ms. Ginyard, who was involved in the tumultuous incident that took place near the end of the debate at the Homewood Carnegie Library.

Advertise with us

The debate also included candidates Andre Young, a businessman, and Twanda Carlisle, the former councilwoman who resigned the seat and served a prison sentence for misusing public funds during her tenure.

Ms. Ginyard denounced Mr. Burgess on Monday for avoiding the planned debates and contended that he was exploiting the incident to avoid further questioning by his opponents. She said the event was not the violent melee suggested by his letter, but a family dispute misinterpreted by some members of the audience.

She said an elderly aunt with a history of mental instability had verbally challenged her from the audience. Ms. Ginyard said her sister and her daughter had tried to soothe the agitated woman, but their actions were misunderstood by some audience members, who, in turn, began to argue with them. She said she left the stage out of concern for her daughter, who was by then surrounded by and arguing with other members of the crowd. Ms. Ginyard’s aunt could not be reached for comment.

“I went to aid my daughter, as any mother would,” Ms. Ginyard said. “I, in no way, shape or form, was anywhere near the woman, my aunt.”

A video recording of the aftermath of the confrontation, made by a reporter covering the forum, shows state Rep. Ed Gainey, D-Lincoln-Lemington, whose legislative district overlaps the Burgess council seat, trying to calm the crowd while audience members, out of their seats and moving around, loudly argue. The video doesn’t appear to show any violence among the participants.

Advertise with us

Ms. Ginyard charged further that her aunt had been escorted to the debate by Carlisle in a calculated effort to spark a confrontation between the family members.

Carlisle denied that charge.

“I went to that debate alone; I was not involved at all,” Carlisle said. “I know her aunt, but I was not involved in her being there.”

It is not clear whether Carlisle could serve in the seat, if elected, due to the felony conviction that ended her previous term. When she filed for the nomination, she dismissed that as an issue for lawyers to thrash out.

Politics editor James O'Toole: jotoole@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1562.