For months, Pittsburgh Mayor Bill Peduto has been aggressively pushing lawmakers in Harrisburg to enact a series of municipal pension overhauls, going as far as calling out fellow Democrats for their idleness on the issue in a letter last week that was signed by nine other Pennsylvania Democratic mayors.
The mayor also testified last month at a Pittsburgh hearing of the House Urban Affairs Committee, imploring the Legislature to “stop kicking the can down the road and to address this challenge head-on.” Among a long list of changes endorsed by the mayor, the first he mentioned was eliminating “spiking overtime,” in which employees are allowed to pad their pensions with large overtime payments in their final years on the job.
Yet despite the fact Pittsburgh’s latest five-year recovery plan under the Act 47 program for distressed municipalities specifically directed the city to “eliminate overtime from firefighter pension benefit calculations for new hires,” the new contract the city signed with International Association of Firefighters Local No. 1 last month does nothing to restrict the practice.
The firefighters remain the only union of the nine that represent city employees that may include overtime for the purpose of pension-benefit calculations.
That did not escape the notice of Fraternal Order of Police Lodge No. 1, which began presenting its case for bigger pay increases and other “enhancements” last week during binding arbitration proceedings. After the union failed to reach an agreement with the city, the provisions of its next contract will be determined by a panel of three arbitrators.
The police union has argued that more than a decade of financial austerity has created poor morale and high levels of attrition in the police department. The union said Mr. Peduto’s administration lobbied to keep the city under Act 47 to maintain “leverage” in union negotiations because of the compensation caps for collective-bargaining units imposed by the financial recovery plan.
Read More
“For 10 years now, we’ve seen inconsistencies in recovery-plan initiatives,” said Richard Poulson, an FOP lawyer. “Basically, we’ve seen them apply the easy ones, which cut police pay and benefits, but shy away from the hard ones.”
The city paid more than $17.8 million in firefighter “premium pay,” which includes overtime, in 2013. It budgeted about $12.8 million for 2014 and $14.2 million for this year.
The city and fire union came to an agreement last month on a new four-year contract that includes a wage freeze this year, a 1 percent salary increase in 2016 and 2 percent increases in 2017 and 2018. The fire union dropped the lawsuit it filed against the city and state over the decision to keep Pittsburgh in Act 47 and will keep the four-firefighter-per-truck staffing it sought.
“The fire contract resulted from a series of good-faith negotiations and ultimately complies with the overall maximum compensation allocations and wage limits recommended by the Act 47 plan,” said Kevin Acklin, the mayor’s chief of staff. “The proposals submitted by FOP failed both of these key financial conditions of the plan.
”While we were unable to agree with the fire union regarding the impact of overtime on pensions, neither side ever gets everything they want in good-faith bargaining and the mayor continues to be a vocal supporter of pension reform in Harrisburg.”
Ralph Sicuro, the fire union president, said the overtime issue wasn’t a matter eligible for bargaining, since the law establishing Pittsburgh’s firefighter pension plan says payments are based on “wages,” not salary, which the union believes includes overtime.
“There is no portion of our contract that deals with overtime and pensions,” Mr. Sicuro said. “It’s all a matter of statute.”
He also pointed out that firefighters contribute 7 percent of their yearly pay to their pension plans. Police contribute 6.5 percent.
City Controller Michael Lamb, who said in a 2012 report that city firefighter overtime was “out of control,” mostly as a result of minimum-staffing levels, said last week that he was “surprised” that a proposal to eliminate overtime from consideration in firefighter pensions wasn’t part of the new contract, given the intense focus on municipal-pension overhauls statewide.
“It just seems to me that the discussions came down to a status quo situation,” Mr. Lamb said. “Maybe their thinking is they’ll get that through Harrisburg.”





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.