Nearly five years after an illegal water and sewer line insurance scheme forced the resignation of a Pittsburgh Water and Sewer Authority executive director, Pittsburgh City Council will consider legislation inviting bidders willing to provide the service to homeowners for a new program.
A resolution introduced Tuesday by Councilman Dan Gilman would authorize the city administration to issue a request for proposals for a “service line protection program.”
Mr. Gilman said neither the water and sewer authority nor the city would provide the insurance, which would be voluntary coverage for homeowners on their property.
“Line replacement can cost upwards of $25,000 and can easily be covered by insurance,” Mr. Gilman said. “PWSA’s former program was well-intended but poorly and illegally implemented.”
In 2010, the authority began charging $5 a month for line insurance, billed automatically unless customers opted out, eliciting a backlash of criticism and a class-action lawsuit. The company that provided the insurance, Utility Line Service, was run by friends of then-executive director Michael Kenney, who resigned that year.
In 2011, after competing firms sued, a judge ruled that the program was illegal because it required customers to opt out and it competed with private businesses providing the same services.
Read More
Mr. Gilman said the proposed resolution, which will come before council’s standing committee next week, has been vetted by the city solicitor and shouldn’t trigger the same challenge because the program wouldn’t be run by the city and wouldn’t impede other businesses.
It also wouldn’t be the sole option for homeowners, as was the case with the previous program.
“We’re simply looking at opportunities to greater promote insurance options so residents can go for it,” Mr. Gilman said. “My office regularly hears from residents who face massive bills when their line breaks.”
The proposed resolution notes that “it is important that the city consider vendors that have a strong Better Business Bureau rating, existing partnerships with other municipalities and have not been subject to state Attorney General or state Department of Insurance investigations or actions.” It also reads that any joint partnership between the vendor and the city “should allow for revenue generation for both entities.”
That is envisioned as a flat fee or a fee per customer signed up paid to the city by the company, Mr. Gilman said, adding that there could also be joint marketing agreements that create revenue for the city.



Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.