Mayor Bill Peduto’s administration is scheduled to release a massive, two-volume fact-finding report today on cost increases during the installation of a payroll module that was part of a 2011 joint city-county agreement on a comprehensive financial management system.
When Mr. Peduto took office last year, he put the brakes on the payroll module project, which his office said had ballooned from an initial budget of nearly $264,000 to more than $1.2 million, was a year behind schedule and was rife with examples of “gross mismanagement, lack of oversight, and sheer waste of resources.”
That decision has been the source of serious friction between Mr. Peduto’s office and the city’s financial overseers at the Intergovernmental Cooperation Authority, which is withholding $10 million in city gaming revenue over the issue, as well as with City Controller Michael Lamb and County Controller Chelsa Wagner, who told the ICA last summer that the implementation delay could cost the city up to $5 million a year.
The ICA long had urged the city to enter into an agreement with the county to piggyback onto its JD Edwards enterprise-resource planning system, which also includes modules for procurement, finance, human resources and other functions.
The report by DeForest, Koscelnik, Yokitis and Berardinelli, a Pittsburgh law firm the city hired last fall to delve into why the costs increased and what oversight procedures were in place to monitor them, relies on 77,000 pages of documents, including emails, city files and contracts, among other sources, and cost city taxpayers $32,000, the mayor’s office said.
The law firm found that between March 2013 and January 2014, Denovo, a firm working for Allegheny County that was tapped to help install the city payroll module, received eight change orders that totaled more than $988,000, all but two signed by Chuck Half, a former city employee who served as project manager on the endeavor.
Read More
“Some of these change orders appear to be the result of changes in project scope, others due to a lack of full cooperation from the relevant constituents at the city in assisting with the implementation and others due to the complexity of the project compared to initial estimates and assessments,” the report says. “Denovo has advised that its original bid was premised on the belief that the county’s payroll setup could be used for the city, but this ended up being incorrect, resulting in significant additional design, analysis, resources and training time.”
Kevin Acklin, the mayor’s chief of staff, said the report illustrated lapses that allowed nearly $1 million in city money to go out the door on the signature of a single city employee, Mr. Half, without oversight or City Council approval.
“It was literally one guy,” he said.
Mr. Half declined an interview with the law firm, which he said came after attorney David Berardinelli refused to provide a list of questions in advance. Mr. Half contended the city had all the invoices, reports and other information it needed to document “the full extent of my knowledge on this matter.”
Mr. Half said Tuesday evening that change orders were the result of joint decisions with officials in the city’s personnel and finance departments as well as the city controller’s office and that payments were issued by the county, which actually held the contract with Denovo, and was in charge of leading the project.
Mr. Half added that Denovo’s quote was “never going to be the total.”
“We hoped we would do more work in-house. It didn’t happen,” he said.
Part of the cost increase, he added, was the failure of the city and county to provide workers to help with the project, which was the result of staffing shortages.
He added that a report on the cost of the project that doesn’t show how much the county charged the city for the services is incomplete.
“No invoice ever showed up at the city without being connected with an invoice from the county,” Mr. Half said.
The report’s authors acknowledged several “limitations,” including the inability to interview Mr. Half, the inability of the city to locate certain materials, a decision by the county controller’s office to prevent certain employees from being interviewed and a refusal by Denovo to provide documents.
Last fall, Mr. Acklin said the city hired Independent Catalyst, a Pittsburgh IT firm, to do a technical review of the payroll system that cost $24,600. The firm, which recommended that the city proceed with the JD Edwards system payroll module, will take over the implementation that has been stalled since last spring. It is scheduled to be finished this fall.
“The payroll of city employees is an important thing to get right,” Mr. Acklin said. “We picked up this mess and we’re trying to fix it.”



Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.