The harassment case filed against Pittsburgh City Council President Bruce Kraus closed Thursday after a heated hearing at which the judge dismissed the charge and ordered both parties to attend mediation.

Whether the mediation session will actually occur remains to be seen. Pittsburgh police Officer Dan O’Hara told District Judge James Motznik that he felt the judge had overstepped his authority by trying to order a victim in a case to attend mediation.

The woman, Christine Marburger, said during the hearing that she was not interested in mediation, but her husband said afterward that they would attend the session at the Zone 3 police station March 30. Judge Motznik admitted there was little he could do if she doesn’t attend.

Officer O’Hara charged Mr. Kraus with littering and harassment in October, after Ms. Marburger, who owns a pet salon next to Mr. Kraus’ South Side home, told police that he “caused a scene” in her business and officers asked him to leave. She told officers she watched Mr. Kraus pick up “garbage from the street and sidewalks” about two weeks later and “dump the pile of garbage on the steps of her building,” according to one of the citations.

Advertise with us

Judge Motznik dismissed the littering citation at a previous hearing after Mr. Kraus testified that he placed the items on the steps for only a few moments while he went to retrieve a trash bag. Judge Motznik ordered the two to take a 90-day cooling-off period, at which point he would dismiss the harassment charge if there was no further contact between the two.

Ms. Marburger told the judge Thursday that Mr. Kraus had spoken to some of her employees and coughed at their cigarette smoke. Mr. Kraus and his attorney, Phillip DiLucente, argued that Mr. Kraus had not contacted Ms. Marburger directly and that he had been receptive to mediation, while Ms. Marburger had not.

Judge Motznik read the criminal statute for harassment, which states that in order to be found guilty, someone must have the “intent to harass.”

“Intent’s the word that I think is important here,” Judge Motznik said, and then dismissed the charge.

“This situation needs to come to an end though.”