A group of North Siders seeking permanent status of a public art project is making a First Amendment argument to the Historic Review Commission, which is in the middle of a 60-day deliberation period after tabling a decision last month on whether to allow the installation to remain without penalty.
The River of Words art project last summer was a collaboration between City of Asylum Pittsburgh and the Greater Pittsburgh Arts Council’s Office of Public Art. City of Asylum’s mission is to harbor writers whose political work has endangered them in their countries.
About 140 words were installed on houses and fences and as decals in windows throughout the North Side. Almost half are in the Mexican War Streets, a historic district over which the commission has oversight regarding alterations to facades. The project did not seek historic review approval before the words were installed.
“We made a mistake when we read the legislation,” said Renee Piechocki, director of the Office of Public Art. “We did not realize [the commission] had jurisdiction over art work. The city and the commission were very generous in not fining residents. I am confident they will develop a process that enables public art in [historic] neighborhoods.”
When the commission postponed its vote, acting chairman Ernie Hogan said the project presented the commission with “new territory” and added, “We need to take a longer-term look at this to determine how our policies may need to be evaluated.”
“We will make some kind of judgment,” said planning director Ray Gastil, a commission member. “We’re looking at what other cities have done” reconciling public art with historic standards.
Read More
The commission normally considers requests to alter materials on facades and additions and subtractions such as shutters, windows, doors, awnings, decks and railings. It has not previously been asked to consider anything of the nature or scale of River of Words.
Last year, Glenn Olcerst got a certificate approving the attachment of a mosaic mural to the side of his home as long as the holes and bolts were in the mortar joints and not the brick. Mr. Olcerst, who has been advocating for art in the neighborhood, is leading the effort to retain the words in the historic district.
He said his hearing on the mosaic panel and its approval should have set a precedent for the River of Words, since the holes drilled for the words are much smaller in the mortar joints and that “no historic elements are impaired, and there is no irreversible damage.”
City of Asylum is not advocating for the project because its role, like the installation itself, was intended to be temporary, said Henry Reese, its co-founder. He said the project took on a life of its own from a simple idea.
“It was great that people responded” with strong attachments to their words, he said. “It was the most successful outcome we could have imagined. Watching the community get engaged through the artwork is precisely what we hoped would happen.”
Attorney Kellie Mitchell prepared a memorandum for Mr. Olcerst that cites First Amendment protections of the words as political expression, a means of discourse and as art in a political context. The memorandum was copied to the commission. It also contends that restrictions against the words cannot lawfully be “content based,” since other forms of expression are affixed to houses, including security signs, window boxes and nationality flags.
“As residents, we are building a community around, and embracing, artists and [City of Asylum] writers,” Mr. Olcerst told the commission in February. “The words provide a visual link and connection between the houses that are hosting them. An overwhelming number of people hosting words are unwilling to pay a $100 application fee and take a day off work for a hearing, but nevertheless they want to retain their words.”
For future consideration of public art, he asked for a new fee structure that does not inhibit large-scale projects.
If the commission requires people in the historic district to remove their words or pay to apply to keep them, many will acquiesce for financial reasons, he said. This would “gut the installation” and sever the connections the words represent.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.