The Garden Theater on the North Side has been vacant for years, but one part of the building’s past soon may be returning for an encore.

No, not the porn.

The city’s Urban Redevelopment Authority is hoping to refurbish and reinstall the large vertical neon sign that spelled out GARDEN and was a key element of the North Avenue block for the large part of a century.

“That sign is pretty iconic and clearly an architectural feature of that block,” Tom Hardy, director of the Allegheny City Central Association, said Wednesday.

Advertise with us

The sign was removed for safekeeping 12 to 18 months ago while the building’s terra cotta facade was being restored. But questions arose about where the money would come from to repair and return it to its rightful spot.

According to the URA, the budget for the theater’s redevelopment “did not contemplate” the reinstallation of the sign. Robert Rubinstein, the URA’s acting executive director, added that it wasn’t economically feasible for the developer, Allegheny City Development Group, to do it.

The URA now is turning to the Buhl Foundation for help. It is seeking board approval today to apply for a grant of up to $25,000 from Buhl to aid in the effort. The URA would match the grant amount, up to $100,000, from tax increment financing funds.

It estimates the cost of refurbishing and reinstallation at $125,000. The URA is working with the Allegheny City Central Association on the project.

The sign was not part of the two-story theater’s original construction in 1915. Andrew Wickesberg, president of Allegheny City Central, said that it was added in the 1930s and has since become a neighborhood landmark.

Advertise with us

He sees the work as “part restoration, part symbolic for the community.” Mr. Wickesberg said many residents remember going to see movies at the theater long before it became a porn palace in the 1970s. The theater shut down when the URA acquired it in 2007 after a drawn-out legal battle.

Mr. Hardy added that the sign has served as a beacon of sorts over the years, drawing eyes to a two-story theater surrounded by larger buildings and helping with the scale of the architecture.

“We just feel like it’s really important to have that feature back,” he said.

John DeSantis, vice president of the Allegheny West Civic Council, said the Garden Theater is one of the last of the early 20th century theaters to remain in the city. At one time, the North Side had as many as half a dozen movie theaters, most falling victim to urban renewal.

The Garden proved to be an exception, and Mr. DeSantis said most expected the sign to be returned at some point. “Seeing that facade restored is very important to the North Side community,” he said.

Advertise with us

Mr. Rubinstein said the timetable for the sign reinstallation depends on how quickly the URA can raise the money to do the work. A “reasonable” estimate would be a year, he said.

What will happen with the building itself is still unclear. Allegheny City lost a key tenant last year when the owner of Lawrenceville’s Piccolo Forno restaurant, who intended to open an Italian restaurant in the old theater, pulled out.

Mr. Rubinstein said Allegheny City and its managing member Wayne Zukin are now marketing the space for another tenant. It is planning offices on the second floor. Mr. Zukin could not be reached for comment.