Big Guys Pizza in Bridgeville is nestled between a small, seasonal ice cream shop and the borough building, along Bower Hill Road.

It’s not an eat-in restaurant, but offers a wide variety of pizzas, hoagies, calzones and salads for delivery or carryout.

Big Guy’s Pizza & Pasta is located on Brownsville Road in Carrick, across the street from the office of state Rep. Harry Readshaw.

Although it does have one table for customers, most of the business is take-out or delivery. Its menu, too, is filled with pizza — Sicilian or traditional — hoagies, calzones and salads.

Advertise with us

On Tuesday, the Bridgeville store filed a trademark infringement lawsuit against the one in Carrick, alleging that its name is too similar and that it has resulted in customer confusion.

The claims in the lawsuit, which names as defendants the owners of Big Guy’s Pizza & Pasta, include unfair competition, trademark dilution and cybersquatting. It seeks an injunction against the Carrick shop to stop using the name Big Guy’s Pizza & Pasta, damages and attorney’s fees.

Big Guys Pizza in Bridgeville, owned by Brian Parrish Sr. and Brian Parrish Jr., incorporated on March 11, 2011, and opened for business that year on April 1. Neither owner could be reached for comment.

Big Guy’s Pizza & Pasta in Carrick, incorporated on Sept. 9, 2014, and opened for business on Sept. 22.

Within about a month of the Carrick shop’s opening, the lawsuit said, the Bridgeville store began to receive calls from customers seeking delivery outside its customary 10-mile service area.

Advertise with us

On Dec. 2, the attorney for Big Guys Pizza in Bridgeville sent a cease and desist letter to the business in Carrick. In it, the attorney demanded that the Carrick store stop using its name and website and Facebook address.

“As you are undoubtedly aware, your business name is essentially identical to Big Guys Pizza’s name,“ wrote Emily Gomez. “In addition, your business is located a mere nine miles away in Carrick. We have also learned that you answer the phone referring to yourselves using our exact name, without any differentiation.”

Chuck Giese, the Carrick shop’s owner, responded with a voicemail a day later, acknowledging that he received the letter. “I will not change the name. You guys can go through whatever legal matters you want to. It doesn’t matter. We’ll just close the doors and file bankruptcy. You guys have a blessed day.”

Mr. Giese said he was angry when he received the letter.

“What I said in the voicemail is true. I don’t have money to pay this guy. I can’t even afford to pay a lawyer.”

Advertise with us

Mr. Giese, who is 30, said he has worked in pizza shops his entire life. His location in Carrick used to be a gyro shop where his mom worked. He used to walk to the shop after school and hang out until she finished each day.

He estimates he has sunk about $35,000 into his 500-square foot shop. He employs six people, uses two ovens and works 11 or 12 hours each day.

“I dumped every dollar I had in this place, and big, bad Big Guys are trying to take it away from me,” Mr. Giese said. “I worked hard for this. This is mine.”

The lawsuit alleges that Mr. Giese and co-owner Jeanmarie Roche either failed to check, or did not care, that the name Big Guys Pizza was already registered with the Pennsylvania Department of State.

But Mr. Giese said that he did research names, and Big Guy’s Pizza & Pasta wasn’t taken — although there is another such store in Modesto, Calif. The logos are different, too, he continued. The Carrick store’s logo feaures a cartoon drawing of a muscular man holding a pizza box. The Bridgeville store uses a drawing of a pizza with a slice missing.

Advertise with us

“We didn’t even know he existed,” Mr. Giese said.

He learned about the Bridgeville store in October or November when a supplier serving both stores told him of the other location.

Michael Madison, a trademark professor at the University of Pittsburgh School of Law, said to prevail in an infringement lawsuit, the plaintiff must first prove two things: that their trademark is distinctive, and that it is valid in the geographic location where the infringement is being alleged.

Big Guys Pizza in Bridgeville delivers to South Fayette, Nevillewood, Collier, Upper St. Clair, Scott and Mt. Lebanon.

Big Guy’s in Carrick delivers to a five-mile radius, with Baldwin and the South Side the farthest.

Advertise with us

“Nine miles doesn’t sound like a lot in abstract terms,” Mr. Madison said.“But in practice that’s light years across the Pittsburgh universe. There is essentially zero overlap between the primary marketplace of Bridgeville and Carrick.”

Mr. Giese estimated it would cost $8,000 for him to change his shop’s name — for new signage, menus and T-shirts for his employees.

“It’s impossible,” he said. “They’re just like me except they’ve been in business longer and have more money.”