A report released Tuesday by the city controller gave the permit office in the Pittsburgh Department of Public Works low marks for customer service, including voice mail messages that went ignored for months, as well as identified problems with staffing, online accessibility, signs, parking and other areas.

But Controller Michael Lamb said many of the flaws identified in the audit — which was mostly conducted on permits issued between Jan. 1, 2012, and Dec. 31, 2013 — occurred during the previous city administration and are in the process of being fixed.

“They’ve agreed with them and have already implemented many of them,” Mr. Lamb said of the nearly two dozen recommendations made by his auditors and the public works leadership, including director Mike Gable. “Director Gable has been very receptive.”

Even after Mayor Bill Peduto had installed the new leadership, Mr. Lamb’s auditors found that customer calls were going unanswered or unreturned. Nine out of 15 calls went to voice mail, and two messages left by auditors on May 21, 2014, requesting a return call had still not been returned by August.

Advertise with us

In a response included in the report, Mr. Gable wrote that the department “had some issues with receiving calls and getting voice mail messages” but has improved telecommunications. In an interview, he said the city Department of Innovation & Performance fixed phone and voice mail problems and additional staff has been added to help answer calls.

Mr. Lamb’s office also found that permit approval could take a single day or as long as three months, that a $1 million Accela software system intended to automate the permitting process had still not been implemented and that just a single employee was trained to approve traffic obstruction permits. When that employee was out or unavailable, customers were directed to leave the permit office at 611 Second Ave. and head to the third floor of the City-County Building to have an engineer approve the request.

“Requiring a customer to go to another building to complete the permit process is burdensome and time-consuming,” the report says, calling for a “one-stop shop” for the more than two dozen types of permits the department issues. They range from banners, curb and utility cuts and valet permits to barricades, bridges, block parties, scaffolding and sidewalk cafes.

Mr. Gable wrote that additional staff members have since been trained to write the traffic permits and noted that the transformation of the Bureau of Building Inspection into the new Department of Permits, Licenses and Inspections is a move toward the “one-stop shop.” The new department is also in charge of implementing the Accela system, he added, though it remains unclear how many permits the office will bring under its own umbrella.

Public Works took a step toward online permitting when a website to reserve city park shelters for private events went live last month, though not quite without a hitch. The shelter permits had previously been doled out through an in-person “shelter day” lottery.

“We had an overwhelming response, just the number of people who went online trying to get permits was beyond our expectations” and slowed the system a bit, said Lee Haller, a deputy public works director. “The issue was that everybody hit at the exact same time.”