Roughly four months ago, before police say he killed a security guard in a Homewood bar, Harvey Scott appeared before a judge who was tasked with deciding whether to revoke his bail.

Scott, 26, of Lincoln-Lemington was already awaiting trial on charges he shot and wounded his aunt’s boyfriend, Micah Goodman. Now, Goodman was dead — killed in a shooting — and a prosecutor was describing Scott as a primary suspect.

The defense argued that nothing had changed, and Scott told Allegheny County Common Pleas Judge Kevin Sasinoski that his girlfriend was about to have a child.

The judge revoked Scott’s bail but, in a separate hearing three hours later, reinstated it. He was the second judge to address potential bail revisions for Scott. The hearings are intertwined and complex, and they highlight the difficult decisions judges face when determining whether to send someone to jail or let them return home.

Advertise with us

“I think judges take a lot of time with these bail decisions because there have been instances before where ... people out on bail commit another offense,” said Bruce Antkowiak, a former federal prosecutor who teaches at Saint Vincent College. Bail is intended to ensure that someone shows up for trial, he said, not to punish someone before a conviction.

Judge Sasinoski declined comment, saying a transcript of the bail hearing “speaks for itself.”

Allegheny County police obtained a warrant for Scott’s arrest on charges of attempted homicide in December 2013, after they said he shot Goodman at Goodman's girlfriend's home on Wesley Street in Wilkinsburg. A Wilkinsburg officer spotted Scott on Jan. 5, 2014, and said Scott fled while police attempted to arrest him. Wilkinsburg charged him with fleeing and driving violations, and Scott was arraigned on both sets of charges Jan. 6. He was released after posting $55,000 bail.

Scott waived his preliminary hearing on the fleeing charges and opted to have a hearing in the shooting case. District Judge Kim Hoots, who is on vacation this week and could not be reached, presided over the Feb. 6, 2014, preliminary hearing, a transcript of which was not available Thursday.

Six months later, on Aug. 6, Goodman was fatally shot at his girlfriend’s home. Scott’s trial was scheduled to begin 12 days later. A prosecutor asked for a postponement, citing Goodman's death, and the case was postponed until Oct. 27.

Advertise with us

Scott appeared before Judge Sasinoski for the October hearing. The trial was again postponed, but assistant district attorney Lisa Carey asked the judge to address bond. She described Scott as a suspect in Goodman’s death and also said officials were under the impression Judge Hoots had revoked bond at the preliminary hearing.

Judge Sasinoski expressed confusion as to why Scott’s bond had not been revoked before, indicating that he thought Scott had been arrested on two separate occasions rather than one.

Scott told the judge he was arrested on one date, not two, and that his girlfriend was about to have a child. He asked for electronic monitoring if he could not be released.

Judge Sasinoski revoked Scott’s bond. A few hours later, a defense attorney — accompanied by a bail representative and the prosecutor — again appeared before the judge to argue for Scott’s release on bond.

The bail representative, not named in the transcript, told the judge the agency would have no objection to him reinstating bail. Defense attorney Amy Lindberg pointed out that Scott’s mother said she had “no trouble with him” while he was out on bail.

Advertise with us

The prosecutor again argued for revocation. She told Judge Sasinoski, according to a transcript, that the district attorney’s office had presented evidence at the preliminary hearing indicating that someone had contacted Goodman “offering him $7,500 to not proceed.” Based on that and the seriousness of the charges, she said, “the district judge revoked his bonds. And that’s where the transcript ends.”

A docket transcript from the district judge’s office does not mark the revocation and only says Judge Hoots added a condition to the bond — that Scott was not to contact Goodman.

“This entire time, homicide [detectives] thought that this defendant was in jail, until the murder occurred,” Ms. Carey said. “The next thing that homicide detectives know is they get a call at the same scene as this attempted homicide, and now the victim has been murdered in August 2014.”

Judge Sasinoski reinstated bond.

Pittsburgh police arrested Scott on Tuesday on charges that he opened fire late Monday inside the Rendezvous Phase III bar in Homewood, killing one security guard and wounding another. Judge Sasinoski revoked Scott’s bail Wednesday.