It might seem incredible that former City Councilwoman Twanda Carlisle is considering a run for her old District 9 seat.

In 2007, she pleaded no contest to felony and misdemeanor charges stemming from accusations that she moved $43,160 of city money into personal and campaign accounts. The state constitution, moreover, flatly states that no one “convicted of embezzlement of public moneys, bribery, perjury or other infamous crime, shall be … capable of holding any office.”

As it turns out, however, there’s no law against trying.

“Nothing prevents [people with felony convictions] from running,” said Chuck Pascal, a local attorney who specializes in election law. “There’s a series of cases where the courts have said candidates have to be allowed to run, even if they aren’t eligible to hold the office.”

Advertise with us

Mr. Pascal did note that a voter or political rival could challenge Ms. Carlisle’s eligibility. Every candidate for office must file a sworn statement asserting that they are eligible for the post they’re seeking. “If you can prove that the statement is false, you can have the candidate removed,” Mr. Pascal said.

But while a least three other candidates are seeking to win the May 19 Democratic primary -- incumbent Ricky Burgess, businessman Andre Young, and real estate broker Judith Ginyard -- it’s not clear who would lodge such a challenge.

Mr. Burgess did not respond to a request for comment; Mr. Young could not be reached. Ms. Ginyard largely declined comment, saying “Whether [Ms. Carlisle] is or is not eligible will be revealed in due time.”

“I realize there is going to be some challenges, and we’re prepared to move forward to do whatever is necessary within the court system,” Ms. Carlisle said Monday. But she said she was not yet prepared to discuss her legal strategy.

One argument is that those who have served their time should not be permanently banned from returning to public life.

Advertise with us

Duquesne University law professor Bruce Ledewitz said he thinks the constitutional bar is "extremely broad and it has no statute of limitations, which is bizarre. If you run afoul of the law at 18, you can't run for mayor at 42. It's no way to run a railroad."

It’s not certain Ms. Carlisle will run. Earlier this month, she told the Allegheny County Democratic Committee that she’d be seeking the endorsement of party leaders. She subsequently failed to pay a $3,500 endorsement fee by the party’s Feb. 13 deadline, but is still mulling a run.

Even if Ms. Carlisle were to win the primary, she might want to hold off measuring for drapes. Once she’s sworn in, either the District Attorney or the state Attorney General could challenge her eligibility through what’s known as a quo warranto petition.

A spokesman for Allegheny County District Attorney Stephen A. Zappala Jr. declined to comment on the prospects for such a move. But Laurel Brandstetter, a former prosecutor in the state Attorney General’s office now in private practice, said, “I don’t think there’s any question that this constitutional provision would apply to her.”

Ms. Brandstetter speculated that Ms. Carlisle might argue that, because she pleaded no contest, she technically wasn’t “convicted” of anything, as the letter of the Constitution requires.

Advertise with us

But such an argument “is not going to be successful,” Ms. Brandstetter said. Pleading no contest, she said, amounts to saying “‘I have no evidence to contest the charges.’ For purposes of a prior record, it’s all counted.”

Mr. Ledewitz said the quo warranto process is “normally very quick, because usually you can prove ineligibility with a certified copy of the [criminal] record.”

Still, legal disputes can drag on for years. Within the past decade, for example, two local officials in Montgomery County completed their terms before courts could determine their right to hold office at all.

Barry Kauffman, the executive director of political watchdog group Common Cause Pennsylvania, said he hoped District 9 would avoid such a fate.

“Hopefully,” he said, “the voters would exercise some discipline on those running for a spot on the ballot.”