Second of two parts

A year and a day after his Jan. 6, 2014, inauguration, Mayor Bill Peduto found himself on national TV for the second time in as many months. Unlike his December appearance on CBS’s “Undercover Boss,” he wasn’t slinging trash cans and doling out cash to needy city employees.

Instead, he was squaring off against Fox News’ Bill O’Reilly, who had dedicated an “O’Reilly Factor” segment to Cameron McLay, Mr. Peduto’s police chief. Chief McLay was sucked into the national maelstrom over police shootings, police protesters and the backlash from cops and their supporters when he was photographed on New Year’s Eve holding a sign about ending racism at work and “white silence.”

For police union leaders, who have sparred with Mr. Peduto’s administration over their quest to win the right to live outside the city, uniform changes and the mayor’s rhetoric when speaking about the police, it was the latest affront.

Advertise with us

“By Mayor Bill Peduto labeling us ‘corrupt and mediocre’ and now our current chief insinuating that we are now racist, merely by the color of our skin and the nature of our profession, I say enough is enough!” wrote Office Howard McQuillan, president of the Pittsburgh Fraternal Order of Police, in an email.

In a year that has earned him otherwise positive reviews from observers, Mr. Peduto’s management of the police, with union contract negotiations possibly headed toward arbitration, has been his biggest shortcoming for some, though there have been other self-inflicted wounds.

Police problems

Former Pittsburgh Mayor Tom Murphy, who served three terms from 1994 to 2006, said Mr. Peduto hasn’t called him for advice and neither has Mr. Murphy offered it, though he says Mr. Peduto is doing “a fine job.”

“My only concern is that he waited a little long to hire a police chief,” Mr. Murphy said, noting that city homicides hit a seven-year high in 2014 with 71, more than any year since 2008. Until Chief McLay was hired in September, the police bureau had been without a permanent leader since February 2013, when former Chief Nate Harper, now in federal prison, resigned amid an investigation of an unauthorized department account from which he siphoned money.

Advertise with us

That gap created a void in leadership, crucial to police performance, Mr. Murphy said.

Officer McQuillan would not discuss Mr. Peduto’s first year or his relationship with the police, though others see what appears to be a steadily deteriorating dynamic as a problem for Mr. Peduto.

“He’s got to take a better, more professional focus on dealing with the police department,” said Gerald Shuster, a professor of political communication and presidential rhetoric at the University of Pittsburgh. “It’s tough to be a cop, not just here but anywhere.”

Mr. Peduto said his issues with the police deal “more with individuals and cliques within the police force itself.”

“For so many officers, they’ll come up to me and tell me, ‘You’re doing great things, keep going, we need you,’ ” Mr. Peduto said.

Advertise with us

Before hiring a chief, the mayor said, he had to build a foundation. That included hiring Lourdes Sanchez-Ridge, a former federal prosecutor, as city solicitor and Stephen Bucar, a former FBI special agent and state trooper, as public safety director, as well as pulling the Office of Municipal Investigations out of the Public Safety Department and placing it under the Law Department. There was also a lengthy series of meetings with neighborhoods and officers about what they wanted in a police leader.

“If you hired a police chief under the structure we had before, that police chief would be basically being fed to the lions,” Mr. Peduto said.

Chief McClay, a former Wisconsin police captain, is believed to be the first chief ever hired from outside the department.

“I’m 100 percent convinced that everything we’ve been doing within the police bureau is for the betterment of the police bureau and the men and women who have chosen that as their career. And only time will tell whether that will prove right,” Mr. Peduto said.

‘Undercover Boss’ flap

Advertise with us

Even though he generally gives Mr. Peduto a glowing review on his first year, political consultant Don Friedman, who calls the mayor a friend, acknowledges some stumbles.

While the mayor’s appearance on “Undercover Boss” gave a national audience a stunning depiction of the city, it also created a controversy.

“He could have done a better job prepping himself for the criticism for all the money he gave away on that stupid TV show,” Mr. Friedman said. “It was like he was unprepared for that and that should have been obvious.”

The mayor, who campaigned in part on bringing more transparency to city government, doled out roughly $155,000 to city employees with hard-luck stories on the show — but has yet to reveal who provided the money. Mr. Peduto has pledged to do so, blaming part of the problem on the air date for the episode being moved up.

“I’m happy I did it, but I would never do it again,” he said of the show. “The controversy over the donors is we just don’t have the final list. We have to wait for one of our sponsors to get the OK.”

Advertise with us

A portion of the episode focusing on Harper’s fall from grace also featured footage of former Mayor Luke Ravenstahl and was seen by some as a low blow.

“I’ve known Bill for 20 years and he holds a grudge,” Mr. Friedman said.

In an interview, Mr. Ravenstahl said the comments from Mr. Peduto have been hurtful to his family and friends.

“I feel bad that he needs to constantly point fingers,” Mr. Ravenstahl said. He would not discuss specific policy decisions but added that he wished Mr. Peduto’s administration success for the city’s sake.

On one thing, he and Mr. Peduto agree: It’s time to move on.

Advertise with us

“We did inherit some things that needed to be addressed. They were addressed by speaking of the previous administration only so they wouldn’t be hung on us,” Mr. Peduto said. He added that it was the producers’ insistence that got Mr. Ravenstahl some unwanted attention on “Undercover Boss,” specifically to extrapolate a story line created when one of the employees Mr. Peduto was paired with revealed he was hired by Mr. Ravenstahl’s administration.

“Those days now have passed. We now own what we have and the decisions that we have made during this first year,” Mr. Peduto said.

One of those decisions, replacing Dick Skrinjar, a parks official who served in two prior administrations, with Mark DePasquale, a personal friend from a politically connected family who was most recently working as a car salesman, was another unforced error, Mr. Friedman said.

“Mark DePasquale may sell a lot of cars, but what does that have to do with the city?” he said. “You’re the mayor, you don’t need to create problems for yourself.”

What’s up next

Advertise with us

Mr. Peduto’s overhaul of city government is far from complete. This year, expect to see reorganizations and refocusing of the missions of the city’s Urban Redevelopment Authority, the Pittsburgh Water and Sewer Authority and the Parking Authority. In 2016, he intends to tackle the Housing Authority.

“The totality is the city is moving rapidly in the correct direction, at least as far as I’m concerned,” Mr. Friedman said. “Previous mayors were so busy in development they couldn’t re-imagine how the city should operate structurally.”

Mr. Peduto wants the URA, for example, to shift from bringing in big-box retail that “drags the money of this city out” to developing small business, housing and rebuilding neighborhoods.

“We want to see that quality of life that people are looking for, where you have a vibrant neighborhood business district right down the street,” he said. “You make it safe and clean and vibrant. And watch this city grow. It will take off. And the people who decided 40, 50 years ago that they’d rather live in the suburbs than in a city, their children will be looking to move back.”

Robert Zullo: rzullo@post-gazette.com or 412-263-3909. Twitter: @rczullo.