Pittsburgh officials, including the police chief, find themselves walking a fine line while they try to repair the relationship between officers who have been demoralized by controversy and members of the black community, Mayor Bill Peduto said Wednesday night during an appearance on “The O'Reilly Factor.”

The mayor's comments on the Fox News Channel came a week after police Chief Cameron McLay was photographed holding a sign that said: "I resolve to challenge racism @work. #end white silence." The sign quickly drew attention on social media, prompting criticism from the police union president and praise from others who posted supportive messages with the hashtag #ISupportChiefMcLay.

"There's been a past history that has taken it to levels that have both demoralized the rank-and-file and at the same time broken the communication between our black community and our police force, so we're trying to run both tracks at the same time," Mr. Peduto said during his roughly 5-minute appearance on the national television show. "It's sort of difficult, but the nice thing about Pittsburgh -- it's a small enough city with only 900 officers that you can work on it on an individual basis."

The mayor did not reference any particular incidents. Local community groups have noted anger at the shooting of a black teenager named Leon Ford during a traffic stop that left him paralyzed; the arrest of a teacher named Dennis Henderson, who sued the city on grounds that an officer falsely arrested him and whose suit settlement was recently approved by City Council; and the arrest and beating of a black teenager named Jordan Miles several years ago.

Advertise with us

Mr. Peduto said the goal was to get community members to work with the officers to repair the relationship.

Chief McLay, the mayor said, "took a risk and if it's taken the wrong way, it could actually...." Then, Mr. O'Reilly cut him off mid-sentence.

Mr. O'Reilly asked the mayor, "Was it really wise for the police chief of Pittsburgh to do that?" noting that events in Missouri and New York City have enflamed tensions between residents and officers in many cities across the nation.

"I would argue the other way," Mr. Peduto said. "I actually think that right now what's needed is open, honest dialogue. I don't know of one problem that any of us face, either personally or systematic problems, that isn't addressed by first having an open and honest dialogue."

Chief McLay's decision to hold the sign drew criticism from Pittsburgh police union president Howard McQuillan who, in an email obtained by the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette, said it raised "serious concerns...By Mayor Bill Peduto labeling us 'corrupt and mediocre' and now our current Chief insinuating that we are now racist, merely by the color of our skin and the nature of our profession, I say enough is enough!"

Advertise with us

Moreover, he accused the chief of violating the bureau's social media policy and of being "hypocritical" for disciplining two officers who violated it.

Chief McLay sent a letter to officers apologizing "if any of my PBP family was offended," adding "I saw no indictment of police or anyone else in this sign."

Mr. O’Reilly said he had invited the chief onto his show, but the mayor appeared in his stead.

Outgoing deputy police chief Paul Donaldson, who is set to work his last day before retirement on Friday, said in an interview earlier this week that he supported the chief's actions.

"I agree with the chief," Chief Donaldson said. "I agree that red lives matter, yellow lives matter, white lives matter and police officers' lives matter. I concur with him on the message that he was trying to send."

Chief Donaldson said that, despite the recent public debate between the Fraternal Order of Police leadership and Chief McLay, "I think that there is a good working relationship between the chief and them. That, I do believe. They took some exceptions to some of the comments that he made, etc. The police officers are very sensitive to their reputation and to how they are perceived by the public."