HARRISBURG — Representatives of the Aetna insurance company and Highmark Health argued for hours in court Thursday over the termination of in-network rates for Aetna policyholders at Jefferson Hospital.

Then, asked by the judge to talk privately, they gathered behind closed doors for hours more.

Shortly before 8 p.m., a representative of Allegheny Health Network, Highmark’s provider network, said no settlement had been reached and that negotiations had concluded for the evening.

In the Commonwealth Court hearing, the two sides questioned witnesses about the genesis and probable effects of ending of the contract giving Aetna policyholders in-network rates for providers at Jefferson Hospital, a member of Highmark’s Allegheny Health Network.

Advertise with us

At one point, President Judge Dan Pellegrini told the parties they have a mutual interest in working out their dispute.

“This litigation is just not really helping the patients and customers in Western Pennsylvania,” he said.

Aetna, which now owns Coventry and HealthAmerica, filed a petition and related emergency injunction request Nov. 25.

In the documents, Aetna argues that Allegheny Health Network and Highmark, by seeking to terminate Aetna’s contract with Jefferson Hospital, are violating the 2013 state agreement that allowed Highmark to acquire West Penn Allegheny Health System and create AHN.

That 2013 agreement says that Highmark and AHN may not terminate contracts with other insurers prior to Dec. 31, 2015, unless it is for cause. But in a letter dated July 28, 2014, AHN sent Aetna a “notice of non-renewal” regarding Aetna’s access to Jefferson Hospital. AHN sent a similar letter to United Healthcare, another national insurer. (United is the largest health insurer in the U.S.; Aetna is No. 4.)

Advertise with us

That “non-renewal” — meaning Aetna patients would not have access to Jefferson Hospital — was set to take effect after Jan. 31. Jefferson, according to the court petition, is a “key facility within [Aetna’s] provider network in Western Pennsylvania,” serving patients in the West Mifflin, Clairton, Brentwood and other South Hills and Monongahela Valley communities.

As many as 10,000 Aetna customers could be affected by a Feb. 1 split, and about 750 Aetna customers are being treated by physicians who practice only at Jefferson.

“It is our desire to negotiate a contract between Aetna and Jefferson that reflects fair market rates,” Dan Laurent, an Allegheny Health Network spokesman, said in an evening email. “We are willing to contract with any insurer that is willing to pay fair market rates for the services that we provide.”

Aetna’s spokesman, Walt Cherniak, said “we continue to believe that the Department of Insurance must enforce the consent decree it reached with Highmark to ensure that consumers are protected from the illegal termination of our contract, which would cause Aetna members to lose in-network access to doctors and care at Jefferson ... Our members need the state to ensure that their continuity of care and access to a stable health care network is preserved, just as it did by ordering another Highmark hospital to rescind its illegal termination of a United contract.”

Aetna filed a complaint with the state Department of Insurance in October, and United filed one, too.

Advertise with us

On Nov. 20, the Insurance Department ruled on two the complaints, saying that AHN and Highmark were not permitted to tear up the United contract. But in the Aetna case, the department came to the opposite conclusion, citing an ongoing “contract dispute” between Jefferson and Aetna.

Five days later, Aetna filed its petition with Commonwealth Court.

Starting Jan. 1, the three national insurers that are active in the region — Aetna, United and Cigna — will be the only health insurers to have full access to all of the region’s hospitals; UPMC is refusing to allow full-network access to Highmark’s under-65 commercial customers starting next year, and UPMC Health Plan historically does not offer access to West Penn Allegheny Health System hospitals.

Having access to all of the region’s hospitals is a selling point for those national insurers when it comes to signing up group health plan clients.