Another redevelopment plan may be in the works for the Strip District produce terminal.

City Councilwoman Deborah Gross, who represents the Strip, is exploring the idea of turning the terminal into a public marketplace on par with those in Cleveland, Detroit and other cities.

She is pitching the plan as a possible alternative to the city-led effort to convert the 1,533-foot-long warehouse into housing and a smaller marketplace anchored by vendors specializing in closeout merchandise.

In September, the city Urban Redevelopment Authority selected Chicago-based McCaffery Interests and Rubino Partners of Pittsburgh as co-developers for that redevelopment, but they have yet to reach a deal.

Advertise with us

Their exclusive, three-month negotiating period is being extended another 90 days to give them more time to do so.

Ms. Gross said she has talked to Mayor Bill Peduto; Kevin Acklin, Mr. Peduto’s chief of staff and URA board chairman; Strip merchants; food economy advocates; local foundations; and others about the idea, although she stressed that no formal plan has been developed.

“I’m interested in hearing options and suggestions,” she said, noting that she is still in “kind of the fact-finding and listening phase.”

The market Ms. Gross envisions would run the entire length of the terminal and include fruit and vegetable merchants, artisans, prepared food vendors, and those selling homemade goods, as well as a large cooperative kitchen.

She also sees the Pittsburgh Public Market, which moved from the terminal to a building on Penn Avenue in October 2013, returning, at least in some capacity.

Advertise with us

Although Ms. Gross has talked to Rubino representatives, she said she didn’t know if the closeout concept would fit in with the type of market she is exploring. She noted there probably is the need for an expert to be brought in to figure out “what the optimal mix would be.”

But she’s confident the concept has potential.

“The Strip District as a neighborhood used to be a marketplace, a hub for the whole regional food network, and that’s been lost, but it’s still needed in the region,” she said.

Becky Rodgers, executive director of Neighbors in the Strip, which owns the Pittsburgh Public Market, said she is open to the idea of moving at least some operations back to the terminal, while maintaining the Penn Avenue location, perhaps for startups in search of cheaper rents. It will be opening its own cooperative kitchen at the Penn market soon.

“Anything that helps to promote the vitality, the longevity of the Strip, we would be happy to look at,” she said.

Advertise with us

In 2005, Neighbors in the Strip explored the idea of putting a 45,000-square-foot public market in the terminal, a longtime hub for produce wholesalers, but wasn’t able to get the space at the time.

Ms. Gross said she has been told that most successful public markets are at least 100,000 square feet. Although the terminal can accommodate that, she fears that trying to mix in a market with a lot of residential, as the URA plan calls for, “makes the success of a marketplace less likely.”

Mr. Peduto said he has not seen a formal proposal from Ms. Gross. He said that any plan “is going to have to make financial sense, not just quote be the best use of a building or the preferred use. But what is the most viable financially.”

Right now, the city, he said, is pursuing the McCaffery-Rubino plan. Mr. Peduto met with Mike Rubino, who heads Rubino Partners, and members of his team Tuesday. He said he plans to meet with McCaffery in the next week or so.

“We’ll wait until we hear from both of them before going back to [Ms. Gross] and hearing from her,” he said. “At the same time I’m not going to rule out if the councilwoman has been able to put something together. But it’s too early to say whether that’s a viable proposal or not since I haven’t had the opportunity to meet with her.”

Advertise with us

Mr. Rubino said he and the mayor “had a productive meeting and we did make some progress.”

“I believe we can work together with McCaffery. We made substantial progress here. We have to wait to see how events unfold, but it’s looking pretty good,” he said.

Mr. Rubino said he hasn’t talked to Ms. Gross about her idea. He wouldn’t say whether he thought his plans for a market would jibe with hers. “Right now, the plan is a collaboration with McCaffery,” he said.

Ms. Gross acknowledged the concept of a giant public marketplace requires additional analysis, including economic impact studies. “Is there enough will? Is there enough financial commitment? Is this a community-supported alternative? That’s the key question.”

Nonetheless, she believes a market could thrive, given the demand for fresh fruits and vegetables and the abundance of food producers and family-owned businesses in the region.

Advertise with us

“It’s a really fascinating opportunity,” she said.

Mark Belko: mbelko@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1262.