For nearly a century the Strip District’s produce terminal has served a multitude of produce wholesalers and vendors. Now it will try to accommodate the competing visions of two developers.
In the development version of splitting the baby, as Kevin Acklin called it, the city’s Urban Redevelopment Authority board voted Thursday to enter into exclusive talks with two firms — McCaffery Interests and Rubino Partners — interested in redeveloping the iconic 1,533-foot-long warehouse.
The URA will take the next 90 days to see if it can merge two disparate plans into one master development. The board voted, 3-0, in favor of the proposal, with Jim Ferlo abstaining.
As part of a $30 million project, Chicago-based McCaffery is proposing to convert the terminal into 118 residential units, including 14 live-work lofts; 20,000 square feet of office space; and 35,000 square feet of retail.
Rubino of Pittsburgh is pitching a $19.4 million plan to turn the Smallman Street building into a giant marketplace featuring a farmers and food truck row on the terminal’s docks and a mix of merchants on the inside, from Amish vendors to those specializing in closeout merchandise.
In lobbying for the co-developer arrangement, Mr. Acklin, URA board chairman and chief of staff to Mayor Bill Peduto, described it as “creative” and a way to keep at least part of the terminal available for public use.
Read More
“I don’t think this building requires a one-size-fits-all solution,” he said.
Had the board awarded exclusive negotiations solely to McCaffery, which wants to purchase the building, it likely would have excluded any possible public use, he said. Rubino is proposing to lease the space.
The co-development arrangement, Mr. Acklin added, will give the URA a chance “to see if we can’t marry” two different philosophical approaches.
“I believe there’s a deal here,” he said.
But Mr. Ferlo, a Democratic state senator from Highland Park, objected to the approach, saying it “makes no sense to me at all” and describing it as “pandering.”
He noted that a committee set up to review McCaffery and Rubino proposals and another by the Ferchill Group of Cleveland had unanimously recommended McCaffery for the redevelopment.
“I feel like we’re ignoring their recommendation,” he said.
The URA, he said, has never selected co-developers in the past. But Mr. Acklin said the arrangement was similar to the Federal North redevelopment on the North Side where City of Asylum is involved in one part of it while another developer is handling other aspects.
Mr. Ferlo tried to press for an amendment to give exclusive rights to McCaffery while encouraging the firm to try to negotiate a deal with Rubino but was shot down.
After the vote, Clayton McCaffery, managing director of development and leasing for McCaffery Interests, said it was too soon to comment on a possible arrangement with Rubino. But he added the McCaffery plan was not “set in stone.”
“I think it’s important to know that anything creative and economically viable will be fully considered by our group,” he said.
He said McCaffery, which converted a former cork factory in the Strip into a 297-unit upscale Cork Factory apartment complex, was thrilled to be selected to redevelop the terminal.
“We like old buildings. We like old historic districts, the idea of living above the store,” Mr. McCaffrey said.
A spokeswoman for Rubino Partners said it was “premature to comment until there have been some discussions.”
Among concerns still to be addressed are the potential level of public or foundation subsidies required for capital improvements and ongoing operations; overall risk to the city and who will be responsible for building and roof costs and exterior maintenance; and how to lessen the impact of the additional retail space so as not to conflict with the popular Penn Avenue vendors.
Also Thursday, the URA board terminated an agreement it had with the Buncher to lease the terminal with an option to buy it for $1.8 million. The company will be paid $640,000 as reimbursement for redevelopment-related costs it had incurred. Buncher fell out of favor with Mr. Peduto when it proposed demolishing the western third of the terminal.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.