Mayor Bill Peduto said Wednesday he would like to see a possible collaboration between two of the developers competing to redevelop the Strip District produce terminal “if it makes sense,” but he stressed that he’s not ruling out other options.
“I’m not going to dismiss any of them without the knowledge of the finances behind any of the plans,” he said.
Mr. Peduto’s comments came on the eve of a vote by the city’s Urban Redevelopment Authority board today to award 90 days of exclusive negotiations for the redevelopment of the nearly vacant terminal, the one-time hub for produce wholesalers.
State Sen. Jim Ferlo, a URA board member, said Wednesday that he believes the agency, with the administration’s blessing, is prepared to award the work to Chicago-based McCaffery Interests but as part of possible collaboration with Rubino Partners.
McCaffery is proposing to turn the 1,533-foot-long terminal — a Strip landmark — into mainly housing, with some retail, while Rubino has been pitching a plan for a giant marketplace anchored by businesses that specialize in close-out merchandise.
In a letter to fellow URA board members, Mr. Ferlo questioned the idea of a collaboration, describing the way a proposed URA resolution is structured as a “joke.”
Read More
“After reviewing all the documents, I believe the 90-day exclusive negotiations should be with the McCaffery group and not some obscure co-development or leasing to the [local architect] Rob Pfaffmann/Rubino Group,” said the Highland Park Democrat, adding that the McCaffery plan includes potential retail space and “they should be allowed to work their deal.”
He also questioned the rationale behind the proposed marketplace, given all of the retailers on Penn Avenue.
“Folks — we have a large urban public market place — it’s called Penn Avenue and Smallman [Street] — it just doesn't have a roof over it! If you push another retail complex under the guise of a public market house and flea market you are going to destroy the character of the Strip!” he wrote. “Who wants to live in river front housing if large trucks and loading docks remain to the rear of the terminal — folks, [let’s] get real.”
Officials with Rubino Partners have said their marketplace plan has the backing of some Penn Avenue merchants.
Asked about claims of a possible collaboration, a spokeswoman for Rubino said, “We can’t respond to something we don’t know about. We can’t respond to something that is undefined. We can’t respond to something that is speculation at this point.”
She added that Rubino has had no conversations with the URA or McCaffery. Likewise, Dan McCaffery, the firm’s chairman and CEO, said he has not heard from the URA. But he didn't close the door on a possible partnership.
“I don’t know what [Mr. Ferlo] meant and I don’t know what collaboration means. We’ll just have to wait to see what” the URA board does, he said.
Despite Mr. Ferlo’s comments, Mr. Peduto said he has had no discussion on a final recommendation on the produce terminal. While he said a McCaffery-Rubino partnership might make sense, he added that there were other options. The third bidder for the terminal is the Cleveland-based Ferchill Group, which is proposing housing for the building with a produce market at one end.
“I've tried to stay away from dealing directly with any of the developers or playing a heavy hand in this. My goal is to preserve the past and guarantee the future,” Mr. Peduto said.
He started a search for new developers after finding fault with a proposal by the Buncher Co., which has an option to buy the building for $1.8 million, to tear down the western third of it as part of a new riverfront residential and office development. The mayor negotiated a six-month period with Buncher to try to find another developer.
Mark Belko: mbelko@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1262.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.