Tension that has been steadily mounting between a city council member and Mayor Bill Peduto’s administration over a proposal to lift the Bureau of Building Inspection out of the city's Department of Public Safety boiled over at a combative council meeting Wednesday.

The meeting, the third on the proposal, ended with council giving preliminary approval to the plan to turn the bureau into the Department of Permits, Licenses and Inspections, though not before Councilwoman Darlene Harris took another chance to vociferously attack the proposal as threat to public safety.

“If it does happen and someone dies, it’s the administration and the director of that department that should be held accountable,” said Mrs. Harris, who has emerged as the mayor’s chief foe on council.

She has pointed to a report on a deadly building collapse in Philadelphia that found the city’s Department of Licenses and Inspections was “fragmented by divergent mandates” created by “decades of mission expansion, chronic underfunding and leadership with different goals and methods.”

Advertise with us

Mrs. Harris was the lone no vote, though Councilman Daniel Lavelle and Councilwoman Theresa Kail-Smith abstained. The plan will come up for a final vote next week.

Mrs. Harris accused the administration of lying to her about the plan and claimed again the move was more about friction between two high-ranking members of Mr. Peduto’s administration — Public Safety Director Stephen Bucar and BBI Chief Maura Kennedy — than modernizing the agency.

“Anything you want to do … could be done under public safety,” she said. “It could be one of your loved ones or mine.”

Mr. Lavelle and Councilman Ricky Burgess mentioned potential amendments that could come in the next week that would give Mr. Bucar a role in ensuring that the new department is focused on protecting the public. Mr. Bucar said he may not be interested.

“If you charge me with being responsible for public safety and I can’t affect it, I don’t want the responsibility,” he said.

Advertise with us

The mayor’s office has said the reorganization will involve creating a new position called a “critical structures manager” to ensure the department keeps public safety foremost.

Mrs. Harris also questioned that idea, saying Mr. Bucar, with a salary of $125,000 and his deputy, Mike Huss at $105,000, should handle that task.

“You’re telling me that both of them together are not focused on the public safety of our buildings?” she said.

Mrs. Harris crossed swords several times during the meeting with John Fournier, Mr. Peduto’s deputy chief of staff, and Ms. Kennedy, whose qualifications she has repeatedly challenged. At one point, Mrs. Harris called Mr. Fournier a liar.

Tim McNulty, spokesman for the mayor, said Mrs. Harris “has made this about personal attacks instead of policy from the very beginning.”