The Milwaukee Police Department today said a top official had permission to moonlight as a data consultant for Pittsburgh's police bureau and touted its reputation for innovation despite years of misreporting crime data.

Joel Plant, the Milwaukee police chief of staff, is in the process of finalizing a contract between his corporation, ESM Advisors, and the City of Pittsburgh to assist with data-driven policing.

The contract is worth up to $32,340.

In an emailed statement, the Milwaukee department said Mr. Plant was using vacation days to do his consulting work. He arrived in Pittsburgh this week.

Advertise with us

“Joel Plant responded to a request for proposal from the City of Pittsburgh and was selected in a public purchasing process,” the statement said. “He has and is taking vacation time and is assisting Pittsburgh as it seeks to learn the lessons from the City of Milwaukee regarding the organizational change process.”

The Pittsburgh Post-Gazette reported in today's editions that Mr. Plant had been the sole vendor to respond to a request for proposals soliciting bids to assess and evaluate the bureau.

Officials in Pittsburgh hope that Mr. Plant can usher in a new era of data-driven policing. That method would use 911 calls and other information to improve how the department deploys officers and make the force more proactive.

Earlier this month City Council approved a contract with ESM Advisors following a question-and-answer session with Pittsburgh acting police Chief Cameron McLay. Mayor Bill Peduto signed the resolution, and the contract is awaiting approval by the Law Department and the Controller's office.

Sonya Toler, the city's public safety spokeswoman,Thursday released part of the contract to the Post-Gazette. She did not provide, however, an exhibit titled "Scope of Work Addendum and Fee Schedule."

Advertise with us

Ms. Toler said today that she could not provide the exhibit because it was with the Law Department, which is reviewing the paperwork. She did not explain why she was able to release the rest of the contract previously -- while it was in the Law Department's hands -- but could not turn it over today.

Mr. Plant was a former aide to the mayor in Madison, Wis. before going to Milwaukee in 2010. He had a working relationship with Chief McLay, who was most recently a police captain in Madison.

The Milwaukee police statement touted its reputation as a forward-thinking department. The statement also shrugged off a series of investigative stories published by the Milwaukee Journal Sentinel in 2012 about how the department chronically misreported crime data, thereby distorting the city's crime rate.

Milwaukee's police chief, Edward Flynn, has told the paper that the problems stemmed from human error and computer failings.

An audit by the Milwaukee Fire and Police Commission found that the problem was bigger than what the newspaper reported, with 5,300 assault cases being misreported since 2006. The audit found that data was not intentionally altered.

Advertise with us

"Outside the walls of the Milwaukee Journal Sentinel, the Milwaukee Police Department is widely regarded as an innovative, progressive police department engaged in evidence-based best practices," the statement said.

Timothy McNulty, a spokesman for Pittsburgh Mayor Bill Peduto, noted that Milwaukee's data problems predate Mr. Plant's arrival at the department.

It is unclear what role, if any, Mr. Plant had as chief of staff in overseeing data or implementing fixes to the problem.

Mr. Plant has not returned calls over the past two days.

The statement from Milwaukee Chief Flynn said, "I have given permission to department members to travel across the country and take part in various teaching and consulting activities on their own time for which they are [remunerated]."

Advertise with us

Bob Donovan, a Milwaukee alderman, today released a statement saying he was "surprised" to learn that Mr. Plant was being hired as a consultant. He said the chief of staff earns more than $98,000 a year in salary.

"I sure hope Mr. Plant isn’t skirting any of his duties for the MPD, or using any MPD/city resources in his consulting endeavor. If Mr. Plant can spend all of that time in Pittsburgh while still doing his job here, I believe it’s time we take another look at his job description, because in my mind this smells strongly of double-dipping at the expense of Milwaukee taxpayers,” Mr. Donovan said.

“The bottom line for me as an elected official and resident is that I want the top brass of the MPD 100% focused on solving Milwaukee’s crime and public safety problems 100 percent of the time – not 60 or 70 percent of the time. How about we take care of our problems first, and let Pittsburgh hire someone else for their issues!”