The chef-owner of Piccolo Forno in Lawrenceville, Domenic Branduzzi, has pulled out of the Garden Theater development in Central Northside, which was to become ARDE, a 4,500-square-foot Italian restaurant.
ARDE was the only tenant for the showcase Federal North property, a longtime eyesore. The theater, which the city’s Urban Redevelopment Authority bought and closed in 2007, is being redeveloped with the Masonic building storefronts, where the nonprofit City of Asylum Pittsburgh plans to house its offices, a bookstore, performance and workshop space and a cafe. While the theater was purchased by Allegheny City Development Group last year, the Masonic building is still owned by the URA.
Signs that Mr. Branduzzi was switching gears came to light in October, when his Lawrenceville landlord gave him the option of taking over the building behind Piccolo Forno. Mr. Branduzzi seized the opportunity and announced the opening of Grapparia, a grappa and wine bar he hopes to open before the year’s end.
“The proposition to open another restaurant after two years of waiting for important infrastructure to be built is no longer feasible for me personally,” Mr. Branduzzi wrote in an email Tuesday. “With an established and growing residential population and unique cultural amenities that attract thousands of tourists, I’m confident that more business owners will be investing [in the Central Northside]. It is truly one of the best locations in the city.”
Wayne Zukin, managing member of Allegheny City Development Group, which includes Collaborative Ventures of Mt. Lebanon, said delays in water and sewer repairs contributed to Mr. Branduzzi’s decision to pull out. He said the URA, which purchased the Garden Theater for $1.1 million eight years ago and then sold it for $73,757 to Allegheny City Development last December, agreed to take on water and sewer work in October 2013. The Pittsburgh Water and Sewer Authority’s approval took some time, and the work began this fall.
“Dom has been very patient over the last year and a half while we’ve been trying to get everything else sorted out,” Mr. Zukin said. “Because of the delays and the uncertainty, he said that his heart was no longer in it. I am hugely disappointed because it was so perfect. We’re at the two-yard line. But it will not be difficult for another restaurant to come in and pick up where he left off.”
He said the building should be ready for a restaurant to open in the late spring.
ARDE would have lit up the interior letters of the theater sign, “Garden,” which was taken down for restoration, but Mr. Zukin said the sign was always intended to be there, regardless of the name of the restaurant. The sign will be returned after it is restored.
Last year, the city determined it was more than infrastructure that caused the holdup. Kevin Acklin, Mayor Bill Peduto’s chief of staff and chief development officer, said Monday that problems with infrastructure had been identified and resolved awhile ago.The Zukin team had been given a number of benchmark dates to secure financing that were not met. When they lost their ability to secure a tenant in the Masonic building, the city asked that they cease their exclusive negotiation for the block.
“We didn’t want to wait any longer,” Mr. Acklin said.
This was followed by the URA’s request for proposals in June for the rest of the properties in the block, minus the Masonic building, which are clustered at Federal Street and North Avenues. The URA plans to co-develop the former Masonic Hall with City of Asylum Pittsburgh as the owner or tenant. That property is expected to become Alphabet City.
Tom Hardy, director of Allegheny City Central Association, said that despite the delay, he is optimistic about progress.
“Yes, it has taken a long time for this project to come to fruition,” he said, “but we’re in a good position compared to where the market was a couple years ago.” He cited safer and more attractive city neighborhoods, the uptick in residential real estate values and new food venues such as El Burro, Allegheny City Market, Crazy Mocha and Deli on North as evidence.
“Getting this moving is of the utmost importance to the administration,” Mr. Acklin said. “This stretch is the keystone for the development of the neighborhood.”
Melissa McCart: 412-263-1198 or on Twitter@melissamccart. Diana Nelson Jones contributed reporting.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.