The verbiage really said it all.

“Thwart,” “violations,” “hostile act,” “kangaroo court” and “a new low” were among the rhetorical barbs hurled during a combative meeting of Pittsburgh’s Intergovernmental Cooperation Authority late Tuesday afternoon that featured Mayor Bill Peduto and nearly every senior member of his administration facing off against the board of the city’s state-created fiscal oversight agency over Mr. Peduto’s proposed spending plan for 2015.

Board member Michael Danovitz and chairman Nicholas Varischetti led the charge, with Mr. Danovitz accusing Mr. Peduto’s administration of failing to provide the detailed information it has sought as it weighs whether to sign off on the mayor’s proposed $507.8 million operating budget, first presented to the ICA in September, and $76.6 million capital budget, delivered to the board on Tuesday.

The mayor and his staff contended that the ICA’s questions had been answered in detail and took issue with the initial scheduling of the meeting. Mr. Peduto said he was notified Sunday that the meeting initially was scheduled for 10 a.m. the following day, the same time he was to deliver his State of the City address and budget presentation to city council. The mayor also fumed that, after bringing his senior administrative staff to the meeting, the board was poised to vote his budget down without asking them any questions.

Advertise with us

“Sometimes you’ve just got to throw your hands up and understand that there’s politics involved and at that point, you just move on,” Mr. Peduto said after the meeting, adding that the board was “rejecting it based on ghosts and whims.”

Ann Dugan, an appointee of Gov. Tom Corbett who has been on the ICA board for four years and voted against “disapproving” the city budget, also was troubled by the tone and procedure of the meeting. Ms. Dugan said past budgets had been approved with much less information, citing a perpetual line item in former Mayor Luke Ravenstahl’s budgets for a payment in lieu of taxes from the city’s nonprofits that never materialized.

“You have an administration that has been working very hard to get us the information we need,” she said. “I think we have enough information to make a yes or no decision on the budget. No question.”

The end result of Tuesday’s meeting was the resetting of a statutory clock that will see the ICA take up the city budget again within the next 30 days as the board and city launch another round of correspondence to sort out the ICA’s concerns about the spending plan, including a proposed millage rate hike, a new agreement with the parking authority to steer more revenue to the city and a proposed rental registration fee for rental property owners.

All of those pieces must be approved by city council, which is taking up budget deliberations this month and has until the end of the year to pass a balanced budget.

Advertise with us

Friction between the ICA, one of two financial oversight entities for Pittsburgh city government, and mayoral administrations is not unusual.

What is unusual, however, is the ICA board’s focus on items that may not be approved by council for a month or more, the mayor’s staff said.

“They’re not supposed to be setting the budget; they’re not supposed to be engaged in questions about collective bargaining agreements,” said Kevin Acklin, Mr. Peduto’s chief of staff, adding that the administration worked with the ICA extensively in drafting the proposed budget. “The goal posts are constantly moving in our discussions with this authority. … The framework is there for this to be a collaborative, cooperative agency, and we’re hopeful that we can get there. It’s not due to anything we’ve done. We’ve been nothing but responsive and cooperative.”

Henry Sciortino, who has been the ICA’s executive director since the authority was created in 2004, said the authority rejected budgets passed on unsupported revenue assumptions with former Mayor Ravenstahl’s administration also.

“We can’t draw a conclusion without having more detailed information and witnessing action by the legislative body,” he said. “I would characterize it as they were presenting their high level policy positions on things, which I respect. ... But we’re looking for lower- level detail.”

Advertise with us

The dust-up over the meeting scheduling was “unfortunate,” Mr. Sciortino added, but not intended to embarrass Mr. Peduto’s administration.

In a letter sent to Mr. Peduto Friday, Mr. Varischetti set Dec. 4 as the date for the city’s resubmission of the budget.

“In the spirit of cooperation, we are requesting that we establish a series of working meetings to expedite a full understanding of each area of concern as well as your proposed responses,” he wrote.

Attached to the letter were more than two dozen bullet points from last month seeking more information on the budget, ranging from “uncertain revenue forecast” to concerns over pension funding, employee head count, police and fire “premium pay,” and the proposed real estate tax increase, among others. Those are points the city says it has addressed in a Nov. 3 10-page response to the ICA.

“We hope we can put any hard feelings behind us and work with you and your staff in earnest to bring about a positive result for the residents of the city, including an operating and capital budget and corresponding five-year plan that addresses the well-documented challenges of Pittsburgh’s fiscal health,” Mr. Varischetti wrote in closing. “We are prepared to work with you and your team immediately.”