Robert Ferrante did not help himself.
The jury that found the 66-year-old neuroresearcher guilty of using cyanide to kill his wife last year said that one of the sticking points in reaching the verdict was the inconsistencies in the story he told.
When he was first interviewed by police in the days after Dr. Autumn Klein died, Mr. Ferrante said he was in the kitchen of their Oakland home when his wife returned from work the night of April 17, 2013.
But when he testified on Wednesday, Mr. Ferrante told the jury that he was upstairs in the couple’s bedroom when Dr. Klein got home, and that he heard the bell on their kitchen door ring, alerting him to her arrival.
“It didn’t really make sense to me,” said Brian Maitz, who was the foreman and Juror No. 7.
“We had heard from Day One, the defendant, Robert Ferrante was downstairs,” said Lance DeWeese, Juror No. 6. “And all of a sudden, the story changes, where [he’s] upstairs and he hears Autumn come in the door.
Read More
“It’s your turn to take the witness stand, and the story’s changing. It’s pretty crucial,” DeWeese said.
Helen Ewing, Juror No. 3, said it was difficult for her to reach a verdict knowing that it meant sending Mr. Ferrante to prison for the rest of his life.
“I had to be absolutely certain, and that took me an incredibly long time,” she said. “It was very hard for me to accept and to believe that he could have done it. But I felt that the facts were clear, and I couldn’t argue with them.”
The jury of eight men and four women deliberated for 16 hours over two days. Although they asked two questions Thursday afternoon -- for a copy of the transcript of Mr. Ferrante's 911 call, and to have the transcript of the testimony given by Jin Ho Kim, Mr. Ferrante's research associate at his University of Pittsburgh lab -- they asked none through more than nine hours Friday.
The jurors who spoke to the media after the verdict said that Google searches conducted by Mr. Ferrante in the days immediately after his wife’s death were key.
“We kept coming back -- it was very specific -- potassium cyanide,” Mr. DeWeese said. “What did he order? Potassium cyanide.”
The jurors also agreed that the cyanide level returned by Quest Diagnostics, showing that Dr. Klein died from fatal levels of the toxin, was the one to be believed.
“We determined that was the best test we could have,” Mr. Maitz said. “The lady that delivered the test had been there 37 years.”
The jurors referenced the recording of the 911 call made by Mr. Ferrante in the minutes after his wife collapsed. They asked for the transcript, Ms. Ewing said, because they wanted to know if the dispatcher had prompted Mr. Ferrante’s comments, and to review how he described her symptoms.
“It was gut-wrenching to begin with and hard to take in,” Mr. DeWeese said.
“His demeanor during that call also seemed forced to me,” said Ms. Ewing who was “horrified” by the sounds of Dr. Klein groaning.
The jurors said they were shocked by Mr. Ferrante’s decision to testify.
“If he wouldn’t have testified it wouldn’t have changed my opinion,” Mr. DeWeese said.
“I think he has excellent coaches,” Ms. Ewing said. “I think he had a year to think about the story he wanted to tell.”
As they were nearing the end of the deliberations, Ms. Ewing said, the jurors felt the weight of their responsibility.
“There was a realization of the implications of it,” she said. “That was incredibly difficult.”
They also acknowledged the Klein family.
“I hope we did justice for them, and our thoughts and our prayers go out their family and friends,” Mr. Maitz said.
“I feel that we did justice.” Mr. DeWeese said. “Tonight, I feel right. I feel at peace.”





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.