When Mayor Bill Peduto rolled out his first budget last month, administration officials said the spending plan’s revenue numbers were the result of “consensus revenue forecasting” involving Pittsburgh’s financial overseers at the Intergovernmental Cooperation Authority, the city’s coordinators under the Act 47 program for distressed municipalities and City Controller Michael Lamb’s office.

There was little evidence of any such consensus Monday, however, when the ICA board voted to reject the $505.9 million budget after Mr. Lamb said he was unable to certify the administration’s revenue estimates and board members questioned the proposed real estate tax increase and whether city council will approve it.

“There are still a lot of questions from my standpoint,” said board chairman Nicholas Varischetti. He said it would be financially “irresponsible” for the board to endorse the budget at this point.

Mr. Peduto’s administration has 15 days to respond to the Intergovernmental Cooperation Authority’s questions. It then has 15 days to schedule another meeting on the budget, Mr. Varischetti said. The budget is scheduled to be presented to City Council in the second week of November.

Advertise with us

Pittsburgh has two entities in charge of its finances: the ICA, which the state legislature created in 2004, and a state-appointed Act 47 recovery team consisting of a law firm and a financial advisory firm that drafts the city’s five-year recovery plans. The city entered the Act 47 program in 2004.

“The administration has had meetings with the ICA and the Act 47 team from the earliest days of the year through this fall and have provided all information the overseers have requested since the latest budget was introduced,” said Tim McNulty, a spokesman for Mr. Peduto. “While the controller never formally asked us for data on a new millage rate, we’ll continue giving him, as well as the state overseers, whatever budget data they need.”

Henry Sciortino, the authority’s executive director, said the initial rejection of the budget was standard, even given extensive talks on the spending plan between the ICA and Mr. Peduto’s administration.

“Since 2004, there has never been a budget submitted to us that made it through the first round without being sent back,” he said. “They need to tighten up and cover some of the bases.”

Mr. Lamb, who said he was unable to certify that the budget’s revenue forecasts from real estate tax, permit fee increases and parking meters are accurate, participated in meetings with the city administration on the budget but described his role as “listening to their methodology.”

Advertise with us

“There’s nowhere in this entire document that suggests what the millage rate is going to be next year,” Mr. Lamb said, adding that he did not receive a copy of the budget from the administration and had to pull it off the city website. “Nothing was provided to me.”

Mr. Lamb noted that he is “confident we’re going to figure this out” but couldn’t vet the revenue assumptions without the millage rate and other information, including details on increased parking meter revenue and permit fee increases.

In a presentation last month laying out his first budget, Mr. Peduto proposed increasing the real estate tax rate to just less than 8.1 mills, up from the 7.56-mill rate that was implemented after the countywide reassessment in 2012 but well below the 10.8-mill rate the city had imposed before that.

Sam Ashbaugh, the mayor’s new director of the Office of Management and Budget, has said repeatedly that the city worked with the ICA, Mr. Lamb’s office and the city’s Act 47 overseers to develop the revenue projections included in the spending plan.

“If they had any questions they needed addressed, they should have asked,” he said.

Advertise with us

Though Mr. Varischetti said Monday that the ICA had received no response from the Act 47 team to its queries about Mr. Peduto’s proposed budget, Mr. McNulty provided a 13-page review of the city’s budget that the team sent to the ICA on Oct. 9. Mr. Sciortino said the chairman was referring to a “specific writing” detailing compliance or non-compliance with the five-year Act 47 plan. Mr. Varischetti could not be reached this evening for clarification.

No one from the Act 47 team was at Monday’s meeting. Attempts to reach the coordinators were unsuccessful.