Bill Peduto campaigned as a reformer during last year’s mayoral contest, touting legislative achievements that included a 2009 campaign finance ordinance. But even as he raced to victory, it became clear the ordinance needed some reform itself.

One of its key enforcement mechanisms is defunct. Other provisions are contradictory: In an apparent oversight, the ordinance omits mayoral and city controller races from the definition of races it covers. During a campaign-season court battle, Allegheny County Common Pleas Judge Joseph James urged that it be amended “between now and the next election.”

No one has taken him up on that yet.

“The law is completely meaningless,” said City Controller Michael Lamb. “This is what you tend to get when you approach public policy from the position of public relations.”

Advertise with us

Some of the ordinance’s shortcomings are arguably beyond the city’s control. Others stem from changes made after Mayor Luke Ravenstahl vetoed a 2008 version of the bill. Among the latter group is a provision that Mr. Lamb himself ran afoul of, and that prompted Judge James to suspend the limits for the 2013 mayoral race.

The ordinance bars individuals from giving over $2,000 to a mayoral candidate; political committees can give $4,000. But if a candidate spends more than $50,000 of personal funds, the limits can be raised or waived entirely, and Judge James ruled that Mr. Lamb had staked $52,000 of his own money before abandoning the race. Mr. Lamb denies having done so.

Waiving the limits helped Mr. Peduto raise more than $921,000 around the primary, including $125,000 from political committees tied to the Laborers’ District Council of Western Pennsylvania.

Still, Mr. Peduto pledged to revisit the issue. “Mark my words,” he said shortly after the ruling, “we will pass campaign finance laws.”

Mr. Peduto did not, however, mark a calendar. He offered no changes during the remainder of his 2013 council term, though his fundraisers stayed busy: The Peduto campaign raised another $817,000 for the November election.

Advertise with us

Mr. Peduto said he continued raising funds for fear an independent challenger would surface in November, backed by donors who’d supported his main rival in the primary, former state Auditor General Jack Wagner. “The greatest deterrent was having a big war chest,” he said.

Mr. Peduto said he didn’t push to change the ordinance in 2013 because “we didn’t have a cooperative administration” in Mayor Ravenstahl. His own administration has focused on pressing concerns like the budget, he added, and while “I would like to have it done by the end of this year, that’s no guarantee.”

Council also has yet to act. “We inherited a real mess in January,” said City Councilor Daniel Gilman, who won Mr. Peduto’s council seat last year after serving as his chief of staff. Overall, he added, the ordinance has “limited the impact of money from a single donor.”

“I would have hoped they’d amend the law so there’s clearer guidance in future elections,” said attorney Edward B. Friedman, who represented the Wagner campaign before Judge James. “I don’t think that’s happened.”

The Philadelphia experiment

Advertise with us

Across the state, efforts to rein in political spending appear to have met with more success.

Philadelphia limits donations to $2,900 from individuals, $11,500 from committees. Before limits were instituted in 2007, “We had mayoral candidates who were regularly receiving contributions in the six-figure range,” said J. Shane Creamer Jr., executive director at Philadelphia’s Board of Ethics.

“The fact that we have an enforcer puts candidates on notice,” said Ellen Kaplan, interim director and CEO of the Committee of 70, a Philadelphia watchdog group.

According to the ethics board’s 2014 annual report, Philadelphia candidates have admitted to 41 fundraising violations since 2007, which usually involves paying a fine. No such fines have been issued under Pittsburgh’s ordinance.

An early version of the ordinance envisioned Pittsburgh’s Ethics Hearing Board investigating and punishing violations, much like its Philadelphia counterpart. But that approach was vetoed by Mr. Ravenstahl in 2008, who with then-County Executive Dan Onorato preferred a joint city-county approach to provide what Mr. Onorato called an “even playing field” among county municipalities.

Advertise with us

Ultimately, the city ordinance gave enforcement power to the county Board of Elections. But the county never authorized its board to use it.

Allegheny County Council weighed two campaign-finance related measures in 2009. Both died in a committee chaired by the current county executive, Rich Fitzgerald. Mr. Fitzgerald opposes local limits without statewide action.

“I’d be OK with [limits] if all officials had to abide by it, from governor all the way down,” Mr. Fitzgerald said. Imposing limits on Allegheny County officials alone, he added, could hamper them in future statewide campaigns.

But as written, the city ordinance “doesn’t make sense,” said Michael Thompson, a 32-year-old South Oakland resident who plans to run against city Councilman Bruce Kraus next year. “A law with no enforcement mechanism isn’t really a law.”

While candidates can sue over alleged violations of the ordinance, Mr. Peduto said he’d prefer to readopt the 2008 model, “at least as a starting point.”

Advertise with us

Paper tiger?

Philadelphia’s Ethics Board requires candidates to submit financial data electronically. That makes it easy to build a database that can, for example, quickly add up multiple contributions from the same donor.

“If you don’t have the data in electronic form, it can be difficult to ensure compliance,” Mr. Creamer said.

By contrast, Allegheny County can’t process electronic filings, despite a 2003 county ordinance requiring it to have that ability. Reports are posted online, but they’re often handwritten and can’t be scanned by computer search functions. Tracking a contributor’s total activity requires eyeballing every page of data.

Mr. Fitzgerald said accepting electronic reporting was “probably something we should look into,” but “a lot depends on the cost.”

Advertise with us

The city ordinance does require the controller to maintain a database that is searchable by contributor. But Mr. Lamb acknowledges the site, Open Book Pittsburgh (openbookpittsburgh.com), is “not perfect.”

City candidates must file campaign-finance reports with the controller, separate from county filings. But those reports, which are frequently submitted on paper, are retyped by interns, a process can create errors.

“I’ve done searches, and people I knew were donors weren’t on [Open Book],” said city Councilwoman Natalia Rudiak.

For example, Open Book was missing every contribution to Councilman R. Daniel Lavelle’s 2013 campaign, during which he raised more than $100,000.

While Mr. Lavelle had reported those contributions to the county, the controller’s office said he failed to respond to letters requesting them for the city. Mr. Lavelle said he didn’t recall receiving the letters, and was “shocked” to learn about the oversight. He said he planned to file reports shortly.

Advertise with us

Independents day

Looming over efforts to regulate political spending is a 2010 U.S. Supreme Court ruling, Citizens United, that prohibits limiting contributions to, or political spending by, interest groups that act independently from a candidate’s campaign.

Since the ruling, groups like the pro-business Americans for Prosperity have been making so-called “independent expenditures” in contests that range from national elections to school board races.

Pittsburgh’s 2013 mayoral race may be a harbinger for similar changes here. Mr. Ravenstahl spent $261,000 financing an independent committee, the Committee for a Better Pittsburgh, that attacked Mr. Peduto in ads that aired separately from Mr. Wagner’s efforts.

On the other side of the ledger, two committees tied to the Laborers’ District Council reported contributing another $36,000 to a fledgling group, African Americans for Good Government. This past March, state Rep. Ed Gainey, D-Lincoln-Lemington, a Peduto ally, told the news site Urban Media Today, “We created [the committee] to knock on doors and teach our people.”

Advertise with us

Mr. Gainey could not be reached after multiple calls for comment. Labor officials, including Laborers’ District Council of Western Pennsylvania president Philip Ameris, did not respond to requests for comment. But Mr. Peduto confirmed the Good Government committee canvassed on his behalf in 2013, and said he has contributed to it this year.

Such contributions fall outside the scope of his own ordinance, and Mr. Peduto acknowledged that activity “is playing within a system” he’d prefer to change. “But you’re always at a disadvantage against the big money. And unilateral disarmament is insanity.”