Within hours of the partial verdict in the Leon Ford case, civil rights activists in Pittsburgh began lobbying the Allegheny County District Attorney’s office to not retry the remaining five counts of the case.
Mr. Ford was found not guilty on two counts of aggravated assault, but a jury that deliberated for four days was unable to reach consensus on charges of reckless endangerment, resisting arrest and escape.
The case sparked outrage in the community, with many condemning the three officers for their actions. There was already a racial component — in that Mr. Ford is black and the three officers are white — and during the trial, the defense alleged that the officers used racial slurs at Mr. Ford while trying to get him out of his car during the Nov. 11, 2012, traffic stop.
After being pulled over in Highland Park, Mr. Ford provided three valid forms of identification. The officers were still not convinced of his identity and ordered him from his car. When Mr. Ford refused, they tried to pull him out, and one officer climbed in the front passenger seat. The car slammed into drive and quickly pulled away from the curb, with the officer inside. Within a few seconds, that officer fired five shots, leaving Mr. Ford paralyzed.
After the jury returned its verdict Monday, the prosecutor told the court that his office would review the case and decide if it would retry Mr. Ford. On Tuesday, spokesman Mike Manko said no decision has yet been made.
In the meantime, one group, the Black Political Empowerment Project, had already sent a letter to District Attorney Stephen A. Zappala Jr. urging him to dismiss the case, while others plan to circulate a petition recommending the same.
Read More
In the letter, chairman and CEO Tim Stevens wrote that Mr. Ford’s paralysis alone justifies not retrying him. But further, he said, “In light of the passions that this case has engendered, particularly within the African-American community, we strongly urge you to not [retry] Leon Ford.
“Your agreeing to not [retry] will also provide an opportunity for some level of healing within our African-American communities between the community and the police.”
David A. Harris, a law professor at the University of Pittsburgh, said the district attorney serves two roles — to be the lawyer for the people and a type of minister of justice, who must ask, “Is it just to go forward on the rest of the case?”
“A retrial of the Leon Ford case after the central contention of the prosecution was rejected by the jury might be seen as piling on and failing to get the message from the jury, and I don’t see how that can benefit police-community relations.”
Mr. Harris referenced, too, the case of Jordan Miles, a Homewood teen who in 2010 was stopped by Pittsburgh police as he walked to his grandmother’s house.
Officers claimed they saw a bulge in his coat that could have been a gun and that he tried to flee when they approached him. But Mr. Miles said they demanded drugs and guns from him, and then beat him.
Criminal charges against Mr. Miles were thrown out, and he filed a federal lawsuit including claims for false arrest and excessive force. A jury awarded Mr. Miles $119,000 earlier this year for false arrest, but found there was no excessive force.
Elizabeth Pittinger, the executive director of the Citizens Police Review Board, said holding officers accountable for their actions would go a long way toward repairing that relationship.
Specifically in the Ford case, two of them, Officers Andrew Miller and David Derbish, remain in the Pittsburgh police bureau. The third, Michael Kosko, works in law enforcement in Florida.
“If we want to change community perception, let’s deal with the root of the problem — that the officers’ conduct was indeed the catalyst for the outcome.”
She referred to a report by the Pittsburgh police Critical Incident Review Board, which found that the officers involved in the traffic stop that night violated a number of department policies.
“The goodwill gesture here is to demonstrate that kind of conduct is not going to be tolerated. And until we prove that, the public will still be suspicious, and weary of the police.”



Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.