The Pittsburgh Parks Conservancy’s preliminary proposal to narrow Schenley Drive between Darlington and Panther Hollow roads has received early criticism over design drawings of a shared bike and pedestrian path.

The conservancy’s multi-year plan to manage storm water in Schenley Park and restore the Panther Hollow watershed and lake includes a proposed “skinny street” that would restructure how cyclists and pedestrians use the drive.

The conservancy is “at the very beginning of the process” of assessing the site for a redesign, said Heather Sage, the conservancy’s director of community projects. “More drawings will evolve over the next several months. We are committed to an open and rigorous public input process.“

The conservancy has a Sept. 30 meeting with city officials and stakeholder groups including Bike Pittsburgh, the Squirrel Hill Urban Coalition and Oakland Planning and Development, with public meetings to follow. There is no timeline for implementation, she said.

Advertise with us

Eight-foot wide shoulders now flank the two 12-foot wide driving lanes. Cyclists and pedestrians use both shoulders, and cyclists use the driving lanes to go around walkers.

The conservancy proposes 11-foot driving lanes that would be arced to direct rain into two feet of infiltration berms on each side.

A six- to eight-foot wide vegetation buffer would separate one berm from a shared, porous bike-ped lane. That would be 10 feet wide, Ms. Sage said. Two rain gardens would catch overflow near West Circuit Road.

The proposal would eliminate 14 feet of paved surface. Ms. Sage said, more importantly, it would keep three million gallons of water annually out of the city’s water and sewer system. She said the storm water measures the conservancy takes uphill of Panther Hollow will abate the need for a lot of the maintenance .

Chris Zurawsky, a cyclist and chairman of the Squirrel Hill Urban Coalition’s storm water task force, said he hopes watershed management could be achieved without altering Schenley Drive so much. The current configuration “seems to work fine,” he said. “I bike it twice a day.” He said he infers from the drawings that bicyclists and pedestrians could be at risk sharing a path as cyclists would have no way to get around walkers if it got crowded.

Advertise with us

The Southwest Pennsylvania Commission has monitored commuter bicycling at 25 visibly busy locations in the city and determined Schenley Drive to be among the busiest in the morning, said Sara Walfoort, the commission’s transportation planning manager.

Squirrel Hill resident and cyclist Mary Shaw said she hopes the process will include bicyclists and bike infrastructure experts as consultants.

In a letter to the conservancy, Ms. Shaw wrote that she appreciates its work and “definitely supports storm water management” but narrowing Schenley Drive “would yield a miniscule increase in pervious surface at an extremely high cost in risk to an important user group.”

Ms. Sage said concerns being discussed this early are a hopeful sign that “this project is very important to people and that it will be a robust [planning] process.”

Schenley Drive "skinny street" proposed