An internal Pittsburgh police board’s review of the 2012 officer-involved shooting that left Leon D. Ford of Shaler unable to walk undercuts the arguments the city is making in the resulting lawsuit against it, his attorney argued in federal court papers.

Attorney Monte Rabner filed the Critical Incident Review Board report of Mr. Ford’s shooting Monday in response to efforts by the city and the officers to dismiss the lawsuit he filed against them in U.S. District Court.

In the 2013 report, Pittsburgh Assistant Chief George Trosky, Cmdr. RaShall Brackney and then-Lt. Kevin Kraus found that three officers violated bureau policy during the Nov. 11, 2012, traffic stop that ended in the shooting of Mr. Ford.

“We believe this situation could have been avoided had the officers followed training and protocol, and Mr. Leon Ford followed the lawful instructions of the officers,” the board wrote.

Advertise with us

Police pulled over Mr. Ford in Larimer for speeding and other traffic violations. They suspected that he was actually Lamont Ford, who had previously been arrested for firearms violations, according to the report.

At the end of the 16-minute traffic stop, officers tried to pull and push Mr. Ford out of the vehicle, and it began moving rapidly with Officer David Derbish inside. As the two struggled, the officer shot Mr. Ford repeatedly.

Officer Derbish, according to the report, improperly reached into Mr. Ford's vehicle while the engine was running and shot at the occupant of a moving vehicle under circumstances that didn’t meet bureau policy. The board also wrote that he came to the false conclusion that Mr. Ford was armed based solely on a “bulge” that did not correspond to any evidence found at the scene.

Officers Michael Kosko and Andrew Miller failed to use the audio recording device mandated by the bureau, and were not “quick, effective and efficient” in the traffic stop, the report found. The report recommended unspecified disciplinary action against Officers Derbish and Kosko, and “remedial training” for Officer Miller.

Mr. Rabner wrote in a legal brief that given the report’s findings, the city should not be pursuing dismissal of his lawsuit. “Despite the fact that the defendants were in possession of their report … they maintained throughout their motion to dismiss that the officers acted reasonably,” he wrote.

Advertise with us

Neither the city solicitor nor the attorney defending the officers in the lawsuit could be reached for comment.

U.S. Magistrate Judge Maureen P. Kelly can rule on whether to dismiss the lawsuit.

Mr. Ford, 21, faces a Sept. 2 trial in the Allegheny County Court of Common Pleas on charges of aggravated assault, recklessly endangering another person, resisting arrest, escape, failure to yield and reckless driving in the 2012 incident.

The civil case spurred some civil unrest in East Liberty on Tuesday night that resulted in three arrests for blocking traffic.

A group of about 50 people marched on Highland Avenue beginning about 7:30 p.m. in protest of Mr. Ford’s shooting. Among their chants were those shouted in Ferguson, Mo. — “Don't shoot!”

Advertise with us

At North Highland and East Liberty Boulevard, the protesters locked arms and blocked traffic, and police moved in and ordered them to move, said Pittsburgh Public Safety Department spokeswoman Sonya Toler.

Three protesters refused to do so and were arrested.

After marching for about four more blocks, the protesters dispersed peacefully, Ms. Toler said.