Walk down Carson Street on a Saturday night and chances are you'll find signs of visible intoxication: slurred or boisterous speech, poor coordination, listlessness and sudden changes in behavior.
For most people, these are annoyances that exist in neighborhoods with a high proportion of bars or college students, where alcohol is cheap and accessible.
But if a bartender noticed any of those signs and served even one more drink to a "visibly intoxicated" person, he would technically be breaking the law.
And even though it happens every day, the consequences can be steep -- or nonexistent.
Last Tuesday, Hofbrauhaus in the South Side agreed to a $15.6 million settlement after Travis Isiminger was served about 200 ounces of beer, downed several shots and later sped down Carson Street, slamming into an oncoming vehicle, killing 7-year-old Lexa Cleland and seriously injuring her mother.
PG graphic: Establishments cited
(Click image for larger version)
The case against Hofbrauhaus was unambiguous, according to Steve Barth, an attorney who represented the Cleland family. There was video evidence they served Mr. Isiminger, even though he was clearly drunk.
But this extraordinary incident raises questions about how bars and restaurants are supposed to deal with relatively ordinary behavior: customers who want to drink to excess.
Legally, the answer is clear: Liquor license holders must refrain from serving anyone who is visibly intoxicated.
As long as that standard is met, bars and restaurants are largely immune from liability even if one of their customers drunkenly harms someone else, according to Mr. Barth.
But deciding how to put that legal standard in practice is largely up to bartenders, servers and restaurant owners, especially since relatively few liquor licensees are ever investigated by the Bureau of Liquor Control Enforcement.
"It's a judgment call," said Gary Pfeil, a manager at Fat Head's Saloon in the South Side. On a busy night, he said it can be tricky to know how much a guest has had to drink before they walk up to the bar, though he has someone at the door on Friday and Saturday nights who will turn people away if they appear intoxicated.
"These people may be intoxicated, but not visibly so," Mr. Pfeil said.
Not everyone in the service industry is in agreement about who is ultimately responsible for drinkers who may be seriously impaired.
"If you got a person in that situation, you have to get their keys, you have to try to call them a cab," said Kevin Joyce, a past president and current board member of the Western Chapter of the Pennsylvania Restaurant and Lodging Association. "You have to protect the public."
But Mr. Pfeil said it isn't practical to ensure that every person who walks into his business has a ride home with someone who hasn't been drinking.
"We don't have the capacity," he said. "It's impossible to determine who's going to drive. To me, it's the responsibility of people who drink."
There are two main mechanisms that enable enforcement of the visible intoxication provision of the liquor code: the Bureau of Liquor Control Enforcement, which is an arm of the Pennsylvania State Police, and civil litigation.
Between Jan. 1, 2012, and May 13, 2013, six citations were issued in Allegheny County for liquor licensees serving someone who was visibly intoxicated, according to Steven Brison, the Pittsburgh district manager of the BLCE.
There were 61 total statewide citations for the same violation in 2012.
"It's one of the main violations our bureau looks for," said Lt. Mark Crossan, the acting director of the BLCE, adding that citations are generally issued when an undercover officer witnesses a violation.
Lt. Crossan said he was "not comfortable" disclosing the number of enforcement officers he has.
"They're woefully undermanned and understaffed," said Mr. Barth, noting increased enforcement would likely reduce the number of alcohol-related deaths.
"I would love there to be more enforcement in areas like South Side," Mr. Barth said. "But that's not the reality right now."
Even if the BLCE is out-matched, the state now requires new liquor licensees and all new managers of businesses that serve alcohol to go through a responsible alcohol management training program called "RAMP."
Businesses can get reduced fines for liquor code violations and discounted liquor liability insurance if they are RAMP certified.
Jim Bosco, a Seton Hill University professor and RAMP trainer, said the program isn't just about training servers or managers to appropriately identify and handle people who are visibly intoxicated -- it's about changing norms.
"There is a social-norming process that needs to take place," Mr. Bosco said. "You'll still put food orders in, engage them with your charming personality," noting that the choice isn't between kicking someone out or letting them drink. "You're just not going to serve them beer."
This story was originally published with images that are no longer available.


Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.