Already facing questions from city council, a developer has run into another obstacle in its bid to redevelop 55 acres in the Strip District and demolish part of the historic produce terminal -- the Allegheny Valley Railroad Co.
The railroad filed a lawsuit Monday in Allegheny County Common Pleas Court in an effort to block the Buncher Co. from moving ahead with the proposed residential and office development, claiming the plan violates a 1981 deed covenant involving the terminal building.
It came the same day Buncher and the city's Urban Redevelopment Authority touted the proposed Strip project to a city council concerned about financing, storm-water management, legal issues, setback requirements and how much access the public would have to the Allegheny River.
"We are sensitive to some of the issues people have brought forth," Tom Balestrieri, Buncher president and CEO, said at a post-agenda meeting called by Councilman Patrick Dowd. "We think we will be good public stewards of our property ... If we're wrong, I will be the first to apologize."
In the lawsuit, the railroad said the 1981 covenant required the URA, which was purchasing the terminal, to use its "best efforts" to continue to provide space for produce wholesalers or "some other rail-oriented use" in the Strip landmark.
But instead the URA has "willfully ignored its obligations" in part by turning over the terminal to Buncher, which plans to demolish about one-third of it so it can connect 17th Street, which now ends at Smallman Street, to the river.
It also has violated the terms by not renewing leases and by forcing some rail-oriented customers to leave the terminal and relocate and by working to create a special planning district for the Buncher project that would restrict the use of the terminal as a rail-oriented facility, according to the lawsuit.
One of those to leave the terminal was the railroad's biggest customer, the J.E. Corcoran Co., which moved to Thornburg after nearly a century in the Strip.
" 'Best efforts' is not terminating the leases of the people there and chasing them all out, which is what they have done over the last couple of years," said Jonathan Kamin, attorney for the railroad.
He said the entire Buncher project, including the special planning district and up to $50 million in proposed tax increment financing, is premised on abandoning the use of a facility "they have no right to abandon." In addition to demolishing a third of the building, Buncher plans to convert the rest of the terminal into retail and office space.
The railroad, which provides freight service to produce wholesalers, is asking a judge for an injunction to stop the URA and Buncher from leasing, developing or disposing of the produce terminal in a way that violates the covenant and to block the URA from requesting the development of a special planning district involving the terminal. A hearing is scheduled for Friday.
In June, Russell Peterson, the railroad's CEO, sent a letter to city council seeking more than $1.8 million for what he described as business losses related to the Buncher plan, including the loss of J.E. Corcoran.
Mr. Balestrieri referred questions to the URA. Robert Rubinstein, URA acting executive director, said Monday, "We received the lawsuit late this afternoon and based upon a preliminary review we believe it has no merit and will seek its dismissal."
During the council session, Mr. Rubinstein said the project would "unlock the economic potential of the riverfront" and enhance the Strip District. The mixed-use development would stretch from Veterans Bridge to 21st Street between Smallman Street and the river.
But the meeting yielded no consensus on council members' concerns. Before it is put to a vote, Mr. Dowd said, the legislation will be amended to address those concerns.
Mr. Dowd, chairman of council's Intergovernmental Affairs Committee, has declined to introduce legislation that would create the tax-increment financing plan of up to $50 million. He has questioned the size of the plan and demanded more details about how the money would be used.
He called Monday's meeting to address a separate topic -- Buncher's request for legislation creating the special planning district on the 55-acre project site. The legislation would specify the kinds of businesses that could be established on the site. It also would establish signage and height and setback requirements.
Mr. Dowd tried to ask Mr. Balestrieri about a separate property dispute between Buncher and the railroad but the developer declined to discuss the issue. The parties are awaiting the U.S. Surface Transportation Board's ruling on whether the railroad owns an easement on Buncher property between 16th and 21st streets--something that the railroad says could derail Buncher's project but that the URA says would not.
Until the board makes a decision, Mr. Balestrieri said, "there's really nothing to talk about."
Lisa Schroeder, president and CEO of Riverlife, requested a 95-foot buffer between the river and Buncher's buildings. Buncher has requested a 70-foot setback.
Asked after the meeting whether the 95-foot setback would be possible, Mr. Balestrieri said, "I don't think so ... There's only so much area to work with."


Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.