Rivers Casino claims its North Shore home isn't worth anywhere near the value Allegheny County assessors placed on it three years ago. And it's gambling that a judge will agree.
The casino is seeking to have its $199.5 million assessment cut by $128.5 million to $70.9 million for the 2009 tax year.
During a trial before Common Pleas Judge R. Stanton Wettick Jr. last month, the casino maintained that its 2012 assessment should be $117 million -- still far below the original value set by the county.
The trial was the result of an assessment appeal filed by the casino in 2010 after the county placed a value on it for the first time. The riverside complex, which features slot machines, table games and nine restaurants and bars, opened in August 2009.
The casino's estimate of its value differs greatly -- by nearly $200 million -- from that of the Pittsburgh School District and the city. They are seeking to have the 2009 assessment set at $250.1 million and the 2012 value placed at roughly $281 million, based on estimates from their appraiser.
Ira Weiss, the school district's solicitor, said the wide variance is in part due to different methods used to value the property -- an income approach by the casino and a cost approach by the district and city.
The casino attempted to build its case for a reduction around the payments it already makes, including the $7.5 million annual contribution for 30 years toward construction of the Consol Energy Center and the $3 million over three years it has pledged to both the Hill District and the Northside Leadership Conference as conditions for its state gaming license.
In evaluating the property for the casino, appraiser Anthony Barna stated in his report that he took deductions against the value for the "extraordinary and unprecedented obligations" to the arena project and to the two neighborhoods.
Mr. Barna also maintained the project was overbuilt at a cost that "cannot be justified by the potential gaming revenue in this market." Revenues, he said, were projected at $500 million a year when the casino was being planned and built, but came in at $291 million in 2010 and a budgeted $362.1 million in 2011.
While construction costs for the building and 3,800-space parking garage totaled $350 million, "there is evidence of significant obsolescence related to its over-improved quality given the size of the local gaming market and the competition for players," the appraiser wrote.
Mr. Weiss took exception to the arguments.
He pointed out that the ownership group, led by Chicago billionaire Neil Bluhm, was well aware of the obligations to help fund the new arena and the payments to the Hill and North Side when it acquired the casino from the late Detroit businessman Don Barden, who could not obtain permanent financing for the construction.
The city and the school district view those payments as expenses, Mr. Weiss said, adding the two taxing bodies do not believe they should be used as a deduction from the assessed value.
"The majority owner [of the casino] is a hedge fund. These are very sophisticated, savvy business people. They would have you believe that once they landed at Pittsburgh International Airport, they became totally unsophisticated and were fooled," he said.
"They claim these payments were onerous, but they were well known at the time. Everything in this deal was well known."
Whether the casino can deduct such payments depends on whether they are expenses tied to the real estate or part of the casino's business operations, said Jonathan Kamin, a Pittsburgh real estate tax attorney. If it's a restriction on the use of the real estate, it can be deducted. If it is part of a business arrangement, it cannot be, he said.
Mr. Weiss said the casino also argued that it should be compared against The Meadows Racetrack and Casino in Washington County, at least for assessment purposes. But he maintained The Meadows is a "totally different kind of construction. It's much cheaper" than Rivers and should not be used as a comparison.
Before losing the casino, Mr. Barden had pledged to make it the jewel of his gambling holdings. Its design and prominent location, Mr. Weiss said, were key factors in the award of the gaming license to Mr. Barden and the subsequent transfer to Mr. Bluhm's group.
"You can't, on one hand, claim the benefit to get the license and, on the other hand, cry poor," he said. "The fact is, we don't believe it is valid to assume that a facility of a construction type and appearance of The Meadows would be approved for this location."
The casino declined to comment other than to say it "respects the appeals process and awaits the decision of the court."
Whatever the ruling by Judge Wettick, it involves a lot more than petty cash. The $199.5 million assessment generates about $2.77 million a year in property tax revenue for city schools, $2.15 million for the city, and more than $900,000 for the county.
The casino has been paying the taxes during the appeal and would be entitled to hefty refunds should the case go its way.
Judge Wettick heard arguments by the parties on March 13 and 14. Both sides must file briefs by April 20 and then have seven days to submit replies. A decision is expected some time after that.
The dispute has not deterred the county from raising the casino's value to $242.1 million for 2013 in the court-ordered reassessment. The casino is appealing, but that is not part of the case before Judge Wettick.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.