John Shick's shooting rampage March 8 at Western Psychiatric Institute and Clinic didn't come out of the blue.

In the five months prior to the shooting, his demeanor became increasingly volatile and he should have been involuntarily committed for a thorough psychological evaluation, Allegheny County District Attorney Stephen A. Zappala Jr. and other law enforcement officials said Wednesday.

Since November, Mr. Shick was kicked off Duquesne University's campus because he was harassing women there; twice threatened UPMC Shadyside employees with a baseball bat; scared his primary care physician so much that the doctor tried to have him committed and then refused to treat Mr. Shick anymore; refused medication and additional psychiatric help from a doctor at Western Psych; refused to talk to a mobile psychiatric review team; and sent correspondence to a doctor in Los Angeles that prompted that doctor to send a warning to a UPMC doctor saying Mr. Shick posed a risk.

PG VIDEO

Advertise with us

By February, investigators believe Mr. Shick had begun planning his assault on Western Psych that was ended by the swift action of 11 University of Pittsburgh police officers who stormed the building, cornered Mr. Shick and killed him.

During Wednesday's news briefing that laid out much of what investigators have put together since the tragedy that left one Western Psych employee, Michael Schaab, dead and five seriously injured with gunshot wounds, Mr. Zappala said he has learned enough to know that in the weeks prior to the shooting, Mr. Shick should have been involuntarily committed.

"Quite frankly it appears that in February [when Mr. Shick threatened hospital employees with a bat] it should have become a police matter in terms of an involuntary commitment and he should have been taken to an emergency room on that basis," Mr. Zappala said.

Why Mr. Shick was not committed and why the warning from the Los Angeles doctor didn't result in Mr. Shick being looked at more closely are among the issues that investigators will continue to look at, Mr. Zappala said.

"There's an issue about knowledge in the health care community about this guy's condition and what was done," he said. "It's an open investigation and we'll follow the evidence where it goes.

Advertise with us

"If there was a knowing disregard or reckless conduct that supports some kind of theory, we'll cross that bridge when we come to it," he said, noting that Pennsylvania does have "corporate criminal liability theories" in its statutes.

Asked if UPMC should have done more with Mr. Shick during its encounters with him, Mr. Zappala said: "We haven't gotten that far."

Asked to comment Wednesday, UPMC, which had two of its spokeswomen at the news briefing monitoring what was said, emailed a statement later that said: "We look forward to discussing this case with the District Attorney should he believe anything is worth pursuing. We believe all our superb professionals acted responsibly and professionally."

Mr. Shick had been involuntarily committee before, in January, 2010, after an incident at the Portland, Ore., airport when he assaulted a police officer, resisted arrest and was speaking incoherently.

He moved to Pittsburgh in July 2011, but why isn't clear.

Advertise with us

Because Mr. Shick believed he suffered from pancreatitis and there are several experts on the disease who work here, "it's possible that's why he's here" to get help with his medical condition, Mr. Zappala said.

His interactions with UPMC began almost immediately after he arrived in Pittsburgh, where he saw doctors for various ailments, including problems with an ankle, the pancreatitis and erectile dysfunction, said Deputy District Attorney Mark V. Tranquilli.

But his actions don't seem volatile until after the incidents at Duquesne last fall, when Mr. Shick, a graduate biology student there, was barred in November from the campus for harassing women by text and email.

Shortly after being barred, and maybe because of it, in November he had an outpatient visit with a doctor at Western Psych's main building, where the shooting occurred four months later.

"He was reluctant to speak with the mental health expert at the institute," Mr. Tranquilli said. "He consistently wanted to talk about his erectile dysfunction and his need to find a wife."

Advertise with us

The doctor diagnosed Mr. Shick as a high-functioning Asperger syndrome patient, perhaps with a depressive and anxiety disorder, Mr. Tranquilli said, similar to the diagnosis the doctors in Portland had given him in 2010.

Asperger syndrome is an autism spectrum disorder that is typically characterized by the person having difficulty coping socially, but with intense interests and behaviors.

After Mr. Shick's first visit at Western Psych, his doctor scheduled a second one later in November, after the doctor had contacted Mr. Shick's mother.

She told the doctor that she was concerned because she believed her son had stopped taking medication that had been proscribed for late-onset schizophrenia.

During the second visit, the doctor told Mr. Shick he should be taking medication, and Mr. Shick said he didn't want to and abruptly left. He then skipped a third appointment with the doctor in December.

Advertise with us

"In January, [Mr. Shick's] interaction with UPMC as a whole began to get a whole lot more serious and disturbing," Mr. Tranquilli said. At various times, Mr. Shick was treated for his physical ailments at UPMC Presbyterian and UPMC Shadyside, and starting in January "his interactions with the staff at those hospitals became increasingly volatile."

Then, on Feb. 10, Mr. Shick for the first time threatened employees at UPMC Shadyside with a bat, the same day he also sent his correspondence to five doctors around the country complaining about UPMC's treatment of him.

Ten days later, he brought a bat to UPMC Shadyside and threatened staff again. Neither incident was reported to Pittsburgh police.

"If he shows up at Shadyside twice with a baseball bat, I think we should have been called," Pittsburgh police Chief Nate Harper said. "These are things we need to look at."

After one of those incidents, Mr. Shick's primary care physician tried to get Mr. Shick involuntarily committed and called Western Psych's mobile treatment unit to investigate.

Advertise with us

"His primary care physician wanted him 302ed," said Mr. Tranquilli, referring to the state statute number that allows doctors or police to involuntarily commit someone if they are seen to be a threat to themselves or others.

But when the mobile unit arrived at Mr. Shick's apartment to interview him, he refused to meet them and told them by phone he "did not require their services."

The mobile until also tried to talk with UPMC Shadyside employees about the bat incident, but when they got to the hospital, the employees Mr. Shick threatened had gone for the day.

Mr. Shick's doctor "was advised to follow up with someone about a 302 procedure, which, frankly, is not the [doctor's] job" and it's not known if anyone ever tried to follow up, Mr. Tranquilli said.

On Feb. 25, five days after the second bat incident, Brennan Spiegel, a gastroenterologist in Los Angeles who corresponded with Mr. Shick about his condition, sent an email warning Mr. Shick's UPMC gastroenterologist, Vijay Singh, about comments Mr. Shick made to Dr. Spiegel.

Advertise with us

Taken together, Mr. Tranquilli said: "In January, in February, in March we see an ever-increasing sort of pattern of increasingly hostile and aberrant behavior on his part" leading up to the March 8 shooting.

Why he targeted Western Psych is still a mystery, Mr. Zappala said.

Investigators have tried to tie Mr. Shick to anyone who works on the first floor of the building and found nothing. The doctor he saw at Western Psych doesn't have an office on the first floor. And Dr. Singh doesn't have an office in Western Psych, though he did live in the same apartment building with Mr. Shick.

"If [Dr. Singh] was a target of his animus, then [Mr. Shick] could have just gone upstairs or downstairs, wherever the gentleman lives with his family, and he could have killed him there. So he wasn't going to the hospital to hurt that doctor," Mr. Zappala said.

Harry Schaab, still reeling from this loss of his son, Michael, 25, said Wednesday that he was angry when he learned how much UPMC knew about Mr. Shick before the gunman opened fire in the Western Psych lobby.

Advertise with us

"My son's death could have been prevented," Mr. Schaab said. "They're in the business of helping mentally ill people and there's one being brought to your front door and you're turning him away? I don't understand that at all.

"Maybe this could have all been prevented if somebody called police," he said. "The more you think about it, the more it drives you crazy."