After nearly two decades of planning, financial woes and criticism at home and beyond, the $523.4 million North Shore Connector will roll under the Allegheny River for its grand debut Sunday.

That early-morning ride should be a quiet trip compared with the soft opening Friday afternoon that carried several hundred dignitaries and representatives from various city organizations on the 1.2-mile light-rail extension. The route will join a new Gateway Center Station at Liberty Avenue and Stanwix Street, Downtown, with an underground station near PNC Park and an elevated one near Heinz Field.

Surrounded by the invited guests at the Gateway station, it didn't seem the time or place to revisit the route's checkered history. But U.S. Rep. Mike Doyle, D-Forest Hills, chose to begin his remarks with "a trip down memory lane."

"I can't remember back then a single elected official, or newspaper, or television station, who didn't support the idea of developing this T over into the North Shore," Mr. Doyle said.

Advertise with us

In 1994 the Port Authority announced it would hire a consultant to study extending the Light Rail Transit System to Oakland and the North Side, at an estimated cost of $1 billion. Two years later, a new Republican majority on the Allegheny County board of commissioners halted the study. They changed their mind two months later, this time abandoning Oakland's potential and proceeding with a North Shore analysis. Ideas for a Downtown-to-North Side rail link can be traced back more than 100 years.

When the project was named one of five recommended for full federal funding a decade later -- an estimated $393 million -- Mr. Doyle said he couldn't recall much controversy.

Even in the 1990s, though, critics lambasted the extension, saying it would serve only the baseball and football stadiums.

Mr. Doyle listed more than a dozen businesses and attractions now in the area, refuting anyone who's called the route a "tunnel to nowhere."

"Anyone who said that hasn't been to the North Shore in a while, have they?"

Advertise with us

County Executive Rich Fitzgerald noted that Mr. Doyle is among the few elected officials who has served for the duration of the project.

"He was here at the conception and he's here at the birth," Mr. Fitzgerald said.

By 2005, the first construction bids to bore tunnels under the river came in 25 percent over budget. The project cost jumped to $435 million a year later, and the Federal Transit Administration agreed to fund 80 percent, or $348 million. Construction began that fall.

Tunnel excavation finished by early 2009, followed by the news that the project could run up a $552.8 million bill because of inflation in the construction industry -- and that it would shut down if it couldn't find $117.8 million in additional funding. The federal stimulus program provided $62 million.

That same year, Gov. Ed Rendell, whose administration had been instrumental in the subway extension, called the project "a tragic mistake."

Advertise with us

In 2010, a design flaw in wiring and cable cost planners $1.2 million. The project was assailed on a national stage in a summer report by Sens. John McCain, R-Ariz., and Tom Coburn, R-Okla. as one of 100 projects that "gave taxpayers the blues." A spot of good news came that fall: The extension was under budget and on schedule.

Controversy aside, several officials lauded the project Friday for providing 4,000 jobs to the area during the 51/2-year construction. Speakers included Mayor Luke Ravenstahl, Steelers president Art Rooney II, Community College of Allegheny County president Alex Johnson, Port Authority CEO Steve Bland and Andy Warhol Museum director Eric Shiner, who noted that the latest extension will provide a direct link between the museum and the artist's grave in Bethel Park. Ambassador to Ireland Dan Rooney and former Pittsburgh Mayor Sophie Masloff also attended.

Rides are free for at least three years, sponsored by the Steelers, the casino, Alco Parking and the Pittsburgh Stadium Authority. The first car, a Red Line vehicle, will depart from the inbound Wood Street platform at 5:46 a.m. Sunday.

Jeanne Clark, PennFuture communications director, remembered riding the subway into Downtown years ago and compared riders' reaction then to "a Kennywood ride."

Asked if she anticipated a similar reaction among officials Friday, she said likely not.

"They at least pretend to be more sophisticated."