Even as she kicked them off BNY Mellon's property, Allegheny County Common Pleas Judge Christine A. Ward found Thursday that the Occupy Pittsburgh protesters who have encamped along Grant Street since Oct. 15 had reached at least some of their goals.

"[I]t bears noting that Occupy Pittsburgh has benefited greatly from their time occupying BNY Mellon Green. They have been able to spread their message -- the message of the 99 percent -- to people walking past and sometimes entering their encampment," she wrote. "They have benefited from the expressive conduct of occupying the land, a protest symbol, which has undoubtedly impressed certain messages upon passersby."

Even more, she continued, the eviction "will certainly draw publicity and may even assist in communicating the Occupiers' message."

Still, in the same 21-page opinion, Judge Ward found that the occupation of the park is causing BNY Mellon "immediate and irreparable harm" that would not likely abate without granting the injunction.

Advertise with us

She gave the occupiers three days to get out once BNY Mellon files a $10,000 bond with the court, which is expected today.

"We are pleased with the judge's ruling," said Ron Gruendl, a BNY Mellon spokesman.

The bank filed a motion for a preliminary injunction in December, arguing that the occupiers were trespassing and creating a nuisance at the small park sandwiched between Grant and Ross streets, Downtown.

Attorneys for Occupy Pittsburgh made several arguments as to why the group should be permitted to remain, including that they believe the park is a public, urban open space, and that by allowing the group to encamp in the first place, that they were given an "irrevocable license" to stay.

However, Judge Ward disagreed with each claim in her opinion.

Advertise with us

She found that Mellon Green is not urban open space, but instead was "intended to be reserved for future commercial development," and "intended to be used temporarily as open space, pending future development."

In addition, Judge Ward wrote that even if the park can be considered a public space in the spring, summer and fall, it is closed every winter, and therefore, "at least in the winter months, Mellon Green is simply private property."

Jules Lobel, an attorney for Occupy Pittsburgh, disagreed with the judge's reasoning, saying the plaza was built with public subsidies.

"This is just one more example of what many courts are doing -- favoring corporate rights over First Amendment rights of individual citizens," Mr. Lobel said. "She really deferred to private property, even though it is designated urban open space."

Judge Ward found that there is no zoning, legal or common law ground that "permits a group of people to take over someone else's private property as defendants have taken over BNY Mellon's property here.

Advertise with us

"There is no dispute that BNY Mellon owns BNY Mellon Green."

Company officials testified during the January hearing that they were spending an additional $24,400 per week on security because of the Occupy movement.

In addition, BNY Mellon has estimated that restoring the green will cost between $70,000 and $100,000.

The lush grass that used to make home gardeners jealous in the summer is all but gone now, turned into mud covered by tents and wooden boards.

Mr. Lobel said it was unclear if his clients will appeal the decision.

Advertise with us

"The problem now is what the city will do in terms of removing them," he said.

Allegheny County Sheriff William Mullen said if the occupiers don't leave on their own within the 72-hour period allotted, then BNY Mellon will have to file a request for eviction.

Should the court grant such a motion, then, he said, his officers would go in and remove the protesters.

"They've been very cooperative with us," Sheriff Mullen said. "In a perfect world, they'll be gone by Monday."

The Occupy Pittsburgh movement, one of many offshoots of Occupy Wall Street, began at Mellon Green on Oct. 15 as a way to protest economic inequality and corporate greed.

Advertise with us

The handful of people at the Mellon Green camp Thursday did not know about the judge's ruling until a reporter told them what happened.

But they said they had expected to be evicted and weren't surprised by the decision. Several said they had already begun removing items in recent days and they knew they would not stay through the winter.

"It was an inevitability," said Halley Katz, 18, of Bloomfield, who has been living at the camp since Oct. 15.

"We knew we couldn't stay forever," said Tracie Doyle, 28, of McKeesport, who also has been living in the park since Oct. 15 with her boyfriend. "It's kind of sad. We've become a family."

Occupy Pittsburgh held a heated meeting in the United Steelworkers building Downtown to discuss the future of their group. Some participants walked out of it screaming.

Advertise with us

"That camp is not the end all be all of this movement," Occupy Pittsburgh member Jonathan Gray said.

Most Occupy Pittsburgh members declined to say whether they will leave by the court deadline or continue to try to camp there.

Mr. Gray said that because the group has no formal leaders, many people will make their own decisions about whether to stay.

The campers said Pittsburgh police and Allegheny County sheriff's deputies have treated them with respect, and they expected that to continue.

They also said they feel the Occupy movement, here and across the country, has been a success because it raised awareness of economic inequity.

Advertise with us

Matt Wheeler, 29, originally from Los Angeles but living on the South Side in recent years, said the fact that President Barack Obama's recent State of the Union speech focused largely on inequality is evidence that the movement has been working.

"I think we've definitely had an impact," he said.