"This is going to kill me," said Marsha Stern, 71, of Onondago Street in Swisshelm Park, as she studied the notice she got from Allegheny County on Wednesday that indicated her property assessment would rise to $166,400 from $70,700.
"I'm a senior citizen on Social Security. How can I afford that?"
The retired teacher and collection manager's property tax bill probably won't double once the city and school district are done adjusting their tax rates to avoid taking an illegal windfall from the court-ordered reassessment. That knowledge didn't stop her, though, from trying to use the county's balky online system for scheduling informal appeals.
"I have seven rooms?" she said, reading the data from the notice. "I don't know where they are. I'm trying to find them."
Ms. Stern's reaction was typical of Pittsburghers who got notices in the mail Wednesday letting them know that their assessments were going up, in some cases dramatically. Many didn't feel that the new numbers reflected conditions in their neighborhood. They didn't trust politicians' pledges of help. And they were upset when efforts to start the appeals process by contacting the county were foiled by busy signals or website glitches.
More than 120 people packed into the Mount Washington Senior Center for a meeting Wednesday night with county executive-elect Rich Fitzgerald and representatives from the city.
Many pressed the city and county on why they weren't doing more to stop this. Others asked whether the judge who ordered the reassessment, Common Pleas Court Judge R. Stanton Wettick Jr., lives in the city. (He does, county and city officials said.)
Carole Carter, 66, cried while looking at the letter that said her home and land on Pinecastle Avenue in Overbrook, previously valued at a combined $76,100, were now worth $122,300.
"I'm losing my home," she said.
Ms. Carter said she has been on disability since 2000, and those payments have now run out. She said she can't afford a tax increase while she's living on the $13,000 a year she receives in Social Security payments.
Jill Harris, of Hallock Street in Mount Washington, grabbed the entire room's attention when she stood up and yelled to Mr. Fitzgerald, "Why don't you tell people to pay their normal taxes and not the difference? Why don't you and [Mayor Luke] Ravenstahl get a backbone and tell them to do it?"
Mr. Fitzgerald praised Ms. Harris for her passion. Michael Stetor, with the city's finance department, advised residents to pay the first installment of their taxes to avoid being hit with fees. If they successfully appeal their assessments, their second and third payments will reflect that change, he said.
Ms. Harris, a retiree who moved back to Pittsburgh from Florida a few years ago, said she was still committed to the idea of protesting because she thinks residents will have to drive any calls for change.
"The only way we're going to change this is 'we the people,' " she said.
Like other residents, she questioned how the value of her home could jump nearly $30,000.
City officials held a similar meeting with residents earlier in the day at the senior center.
Dan Smith, 29, of Elliott's Elkton Street said his assessment went from $51,100 to $75,600. That doesn't seem accurate, he said, because he tried to sell the house for around $80,000 but couldn't find a buyer.
A products manager for a lab equipment firm, he said the value of the house he bought three years ago has declined because of a vacant, decaying structure next door. "The windows are all broken. The roof looks like it's going to fall in," but so far he can't get the city to tear it down, he said.
Ken Herz of Squirrel Hill tried to schedule an informal appeal through the website provided by the county. He said he tried every possible date and was not able to find an open hearing time.
He also tried -- unsuccessfully -- calling the phone number listed by the county. "That was the most predictable busy signal of my entire life," he said. "You'd be lucky to get through on a normal day."
Representatives from the city and county advised people to continue trying to call or access the website, noting that the system was probably busy because many people had just received their assessments and were trying to schedule appeals at the same time. They also promised to deliver appeals forms to the Mount Washington Senior Center today to help people who don't have computer access.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.