Erie County Executive Barry Grossman has mixed feelings about a pending deal in which tax-exempt UPMC Hamot hospital will give nearly $1.2 million a year to the city, county and school district.

On the one hand, he's grateful for the money from the region's dominant hospital, which has been making payments since 1993 as part of a legal settlement.

But he also knows that the medical facility, which is contributing only half of what it would have to pay if it were taxable, could one day end the deal.

"It's a pretty generous agreement," Mr. Grossman said. "We're happy with it. We're glad they're renewing it. But my fear is down the road what's going to happen with this agreement?"

Advertise with us

Indeed, if Hamot -- which became affiliated with UPMC in February -- opted to end its payments, there is little Mr. Grossman could do about it.

That's the tricky nature of the deal, known as a PILOT agreement -- payment in lieu of taxes. It provides a benefit, but it is completely voluntary, leaving the recipient at the mercy of the donor.

And ironically, the creation of the Hamot agreement -- the result of a compromise following Erie's legal challenge of the hospital's tax status -- helped create the very conditions today that have made it exponentially more difficult to mount those challenges.

That reality is also why experts say it is unlikely any UPMC hospital will ever have its tax-exempt status successfully challenged.

Erie's deal has its roots in a seminal 1985 state Supreme Court decision, Hospital Utilization Project (HUP) vs. Commonwealth of Pennsylvania.

Advertise with us

The state Department of Revenue determined that HUP, an association of hospitals that collected and sold health-care data, was not charitable and therefore did not merit a tax exemption.

The court agreed. It created a landmark test that said an entity is a "purely public charity" deserving of tax exemptions if it meets certain criteria. They include donating a substantial portion of its services, relieving government of a burden and operating free from a private profit motive.

"The Supreme Court with HUP went through a history of cases and found five standards," said Nicholas Cafardi, a Duquesne University law school professor and nonprofit expert. "But what was important is then they went and added the word 'and' so you have to meet all five standards, which was never the test before. Before you only had to meet a majority of any standards."

Attorneys quickly saw that the five-part test could be difficult for a nonprofit to meet. Legal challenges -- or threats of them -- blossomed.

"When the HUP test came, there's no doubt that that court case opened up an arena that was previously closed," said Jim Turner, chief administrative officer for former Pittsburgh Mayor Sophie Masloff."

Advertise with us

In the late 1980s and 1990s, Pittsburgh and Allegheny County aggressively challenged the tax-exempt status of nonprofits. Their push came amid declining population, a shrinking tax base and the growth of nonprofit real estate portfolios, which led to an increasing amount of land leaving the tax rolls.

Attorneys for Pittsburgh and Allegheny County dragged one nonprofit after another into court, before property tax appeals boards or into negotiating sessions, including the Central Blood Bank, the Golden Triangle YMCA and Allegheny General Hospital.

City officials at the time believed that local colleges and universities could withstand a legal challenge, but not the medical facilities.

"Hospitals had trouble showing they gave much away," said Ira Weiss, one of the state's most active lawyers in terms of challenging the tax status of nonprofits.

In 1990, Mr. Weiss, the county's deputy solicitor at the time, argued that hospitals "do not operate as charities. [They are] cash cows which generate and pump tax-free dollars into other profit-making ventures."

Advertise with us

In her budget address that year, Ms. Masloff proposed settling the battle with city hospitals over their tax-exempt status by dropping challenges in exchange for them paying a state fee.

"We will gladly join you in partnership in Harrisburg," she warned them, "or we will see you in court."

Pittsburgh's early successes helped fuel a statewide attack on the tax status of nonprofits.

One 1998 study calculated that 175 of the state's 220 private, nonprofit hospitals had their tax status challenged between 1985 and 1996. In some cases, cities, counties and school districts were able to wring contributions from nonprofit groups.

"The original PILOTs came about almost through something that resembled extortion," said Gary M. Grobman, former head of the nonprofit Pennsylvania Jewish Coalition and author of "The Pennsylvania Nonprofit Handbook."

Advertise with us

Mr. Turner recalls the era as an "ugly" time, but said the city had no alternative. Some negotiations went smoothly, he recalled, such as with Presbyterian University Hospital. In 1988, the facility agreed to pay Pittsburgh $11.1 million over 10 years.

That set the stage for other deals.

"They were very reasonable and out of that, once they came on board, then it was a matter of starting to literally pick off hospitals one at a time. I hate that terminology, but that's exactly what happened," Mr. Turner said.

Also in 1988, Erie demanded that Hamot Medical Center pay $100,000 or face a tax challenge.

There could not have been a better target.

Advertise with us

"It was sort of the Darth Vader of the hospitals," Mr. Grobman said. "They had a marina. They acted like a for-profit in almost every respect. They did all these real estate deals. The charity they did was mostly after people couldn't pay their bills, they sent their debt collectors and they said, 'This is the charity we do' when they couldn't collect the money, and then they claimed they were tax exempt."

Hamot refused to back down. The matter wound up in court. A lower court found that Hamot did not meet four of the five criteria of the HUP test. Commonwealth Court eventually upheld the decision stripping Hamot of its nonprofit status.

It marked the first time the HUP test had been applied to a hospital, and the result emboldened taxing bodies across the state.

Hamot brokered a deal to short-circuit the court decision; it would pay money in return for keeping its tax exemption.

Hamot's legacy benefited the Erie area. The case became an icon of a significant victory for taxing bodies trying to challenge the exemptions of hospitals around the state.

Advertise with us

But the Hamot case also helped spark the nonprofit backlash against the HUP test and the myriad tax challenges that had been launched against the sector.

With nonprofits feeling under siege, they took their cause to Harrisburg.

Mr. Grobman, who had helped create the Nonprofit Advocacy Network, a coalition formed to deal with the mounting tax challenges, went to work as a consultant for the Republicans in the General Assembly.

In that capacity, he helped write a new law that took effect in 1997. Act 55, the Institutions of Purely Public Charity Act was the nonprofits' answer to HUP.

Act 55 spells out standards for nonprofits that mirror the general categories of the HUP test but provide specific thresholds for how groups can meet each of the five prongs.

Advertise with us

Critics contend that Act 55 made it far more difficult to mount successful tax challenges against nonprofits.

One reason, they claim: Key portions were drafted by health system lobbyists to make it easier for hospitals to meet the tests.

"The law was written by the Hospital [& Healthsystem] Association of Pennsylvania. There's no question about that," Mr. Weiss said. "Act 55 put what I call a bulletproof vest on large nonprofits because the definition of what each of these tests were written to fit how they do business."

John Geiger, executive director of the Pennsylvania Association of Nonprofit Organizations, disagrees.

"Act 55 was not written by hospital lobbyists. It was written by a collaboration of nonprofits of all types, of all different kinds of nonprofits. It went through a negotiation process. It would be fun to say at this point that hospitals maneuvered that bill."

Advertise with us

That's exactly what happened, according to Mr. Grobman. He said he pushed for tougher language, but he was not heeded.

Mr. Turner viewed Act 55 as the death knell for legal challenges.

It did, however, provide for voluntary PILOT agreements.

Hamot's deal with its local taxing bodies is a case in point. While the hospital continues to pay, local leaders live on tenterhooks wondering if the next PILOT will be the last.

"I don't think taxation or things in lieu of taxation ought to be voluntary or arbitrary, and that's what these programs are, Mr. Grossman said. "The Legislature could clear this up in a heartbeat."