Public defenders' offices tend to attract young, idealistic, driven attorneys who think they can change the world.

Because most of those new hires are straight out of law school, they have little, if any, courtroom experience.

That's why, experts say, it's essential that they receive some kind of on-the-job training -- whether through a formal curriculum or through a mentoring program.

In Allegheny County, the PD's office for many years had no such program. But after a 1996 class-action lawsuit led to a settlement agreement between the county and the ACLU, the PD's office created a full-time training coordinator position.

Advertise with us

That lasted two years, said Chief Public Defender Michael Machen, before the coordinator quit. He was replaced by two attorneys in the office who shared the duties.

But after two more years, that program fell through, too.

Since then, the public defenders say they have been left to seek out the expertise of their more experienced colleagues, or to find formal training workshops offered through legal organizations across the state.

"We would like to provide as much training as possible, but there are resource issues," said County Manager Jim Flynn. But then, he continued, "If employees feel they need more training, then we have to find a way to get it to them."

On Wednesday, Mr. Machen offered the position of full-time training coordinator to assistant public defender Michelle L. Collins, an attorney in the office who specializes in sex crimes.

Advertise with us

She has a master's degree in education and has worked in the office since 1990. On Thursday, she accepted the position.

Mr. Machen said over the past two years, he has tried to put a training program in place by offering his attorneys trips to statewide workshops, as well as through an interim program on trial advocacy that his office puts on.

"We make huge efforts to provide training. We have everything a lawyer could want to do a quality job," he said.

In addition, Mr. Machen said in recent years he has brought in outside attorneys to lead training workshops for his staff. However, the only one he mentioned and that several attorneys remembered was for a session on DUI law.

In recent months, Mr. Machen said the former training director for the Defender Association of Philadelphia completed a juvenile workshop and is expected to return in the next several months for another session.

Advertise with us

Still, one public defender said he has had no training since he began.

"We just have zero leadership," he said. "I showed up on the first day. 'Here's a bunch of cases. Just go to it.'"

Another added, "You're getting felonies right off the bat."

In the case of a recently hired attorney, who was to start last week, the trial supervisor for the PD's office, John Fenner, sent out an email seeking help to train the new woman.

"We'll need several volunteers to introduce our newest attorney ... to substantive criminal law as well as procedure," he wrote.

Advertise with us

He went on to say that the new hire would receive training for two weeks. Mr. Fenner then wrote, "Volunteers may teach any subject they are comfortable with or specialize in. Ask yourself what you wish you had known when you first started."

Mary DeFusco, the director of training and recruitment for the Defender Association of Philadelphia, questioned the process offered by Mr. Fenner.

"Shouldn't the training coordinator ask the person with the best expertise in an area or with the best training skills to do a particular training, and shouldn't they schedule the trainings in an orderly fashion so that one training builds upon another?" she asked.

The Philadelphia office has long been regarded as having one of the best indigent defense training systems in the country.

It created a full-time training director in 1982 and has maintained the position since.

Advertise with us

"We don't think our clients should be guinea pigs," said Ms. DeFusco, who took over the role in 1995.

When she hears of cases from other jurisdictions where new lawyers are thrown into the middle of complicated cases, she said she shudders.

"Holy merciful mother of God," she said. "It's a really bad practice. That's how innocent people go to jail."

In the Philadelphia office, new attorneys spend months working at each stage of a criminal case before they are eligible to work on a felony case -- usually more than a year after starting.

A felony jury trial doesn't occur until about 21/2 years.

Advertise with us

"They've cross-examined hundreds of witnesses before they get to their first jury trial," Ms. DeFusco said.

The training includes things as obvious as making sure young lawyers know to say, " 'Good morning, your honor.'"

"When you're new, how would you know that unless someone shows you?" she asked.

New attorneys are taken through the entire system, from arrest to preliminary arraignment to rules of evidence and procedure, to cross-examination to sentencing.

Built in is a lot of time for observation of real-life cases, as well as role playing.

Advertise with us

Ms. DeFusco dedicates two full days to client interviewing.

"Through every step in this process, the supervisors are watching you in the courtroom, and they review the file," she said. "There's a lot of review."

During a recent hearing, one of the new attorneys ran into a difficult situation, and Ms. DeFusco stepped in and took over the case.

"Yes, I have their backs, but mostly, I have the client's back," she said.

In addition to the lack of training, attorneys in the Allegheny County PD's office also complain that they receive no feedback on the work they've already done.

Advertise with us

For years after the settlement agreement ended, no performance reviews were done for any of the public defenders.

However, in recent months, a few reviews were held.

In most cases, the attorneys said, they were self-evaluations that supervisors signed off on, with no feedback of any kind.

The public defenders who spoke anonymously said the only thing that ensures they do their jobs well is their "own personal sense of integrity."

Mr. Machen acknowledged that his office needs more oversight.

Advertise with us

"One of the things in the future is greater supervision," he said. "Better file review. That's the key."

Mr. Machen has requested funding for two additional supervisors in his office, but the county administration has not yet approved it.