A report released three years ago about the performance of the Allegheny County public defender's office concluded that those people who work there believe they are viewed by others in the court system as the "stepchild."

That same perception continues.

Even though they are county employees just like their counterparts in the district attorney's office, the public defenders say that they are treated differently in ways as simple as Internet usage policies and holidays and as complex as budgets, expenses and promotions.

One of the biggest complaints from the public defenders in the office is that they rarely have the opportunity to be promoted and therefore miss out on pay increases.

Advertise with us

Lawyers for both offices, which share the same union, are categorized by levels -- 4, for the newest, then 3, then 2, for the highest tier.

According to a list circulated by the attorneys' union representatives last year, the numbers between the PD's office and the DA's office are similar for categories 4 and 2.

There were 58 lawyers at the No. 4 level in the PD's office, and 52 people in the DA's office at that level.

The DA's office had 11 people at level 2, earning between $61,000 and $73,000. The PD's office had 10 people in the No. 2 tier, earning between $67,000 and $73,000.

However, in the category for No. 3s, while the DA's office employs 33 people in that group -- mostly attorneys who have been assigned to specialized units -- earning $49,000 to $70,000 annually -- the public defender's office had none.

Advertise with us

"There was a time where, if somebody left a position, I think the PD's office was not replacing that [level] with someone from within," said county manager Jim Flynn. "Instead they would hire someone at entry level."

The issue was brought to his attention a while ago, he said, and that process has been stopped. The idea now is that when someone at a higher level leaves, a lower-level attorney can bid for the position.

Although both agencies must get their budgets approved by the county, if the public defender wants to promote someone mid-year, or give a raise, it has to be approved by the county administration.

While the budget office oversees the DA's available funds, it is the prosecutor's discretion on how to use them.

"The inequities don't go past my face," Mr. Machen said. "I'm not oblivious to it."

Advertise with us

Attorneys in the public defender's office feel that the budgetary constraints placed on them are limiting their ability to do their jobs well.

They are under orders not to order transcripts from preliminary hearings because they are too costly.

"How do you prepare for a trial? How do you find inconsistencies from what they said on the stand with what they told police if you don't have a transcript?" asked former assistant public defender Jimmy Sheets, who is now in private practice.

But Mr. Machen said that in an office where 98 percent of cases end in guilty pleas, transcripts are not always necessary.

When the attorneys in the PD's office recently learned that their Internet usage was being restricted -- although if a request is made, a blocked site can be made available -- they became frustrated.

Advertise with us

"It's a lack of respect accorded to professionals," said one attorney in the PD's office. "It's insulting. It goes directly to morale."

When an attorney complained about the disparity, the supervisor made light of the situation.

"It didn't matter to him that we weren't being treated equally on this minor issue, which is representative of the way we're treated overall."

Another example cited is the number of holidays the two offices get. Employees with the district attorney's office get all of the same holidays offered by the Court of Common Pleas -- including Flag Day, Good Friday, Election Day and the day after Thanksgiving -- whereas the PD's office follows the Allegheny County holiday schedule and gets four fewer days a year.

As an example of cutbacks, the public defender's staff received an email last year instructing them that no more pens would be ordered for the rest of the year.

Advertise with us

A former office manager, Madonna Melle, wrote on July 7, 2010, "I know this might seem petty or even trivial, but please watch your blue pens. I just ordered six dozen about one month ago, and now they are gone. This will be the last time I am ordering blue pens for the office. If you lose them or someone keeps picking them up, sorry, no more. You will have to purchase them yourself. This is getting ridiculous. Things are tight and we have to cut back on the little things if possible."

After receiving that email, assistant public defender Hart Hillman, who won $100 on a scratch-off lottery ticket, went to Sam's Club and bought the office a gross of pens.

Money, he said, "is always an issue in our office."

Mr. Machen said that he regularly solicits grants, donations or supplies from various organizations or businesses.

"We need money, and we need money badly," he said. "I travel around the state and beg for money."

Advertise with us

He even put in a request to Dell to see if the company would be willing to donate tablet computers to his office for the lawyers to use.

He didn't get a response.

As far as inequities between the DA's office and PD's office, Mr. Sheets saw them.

"At the DA's office, you have the possibility of working your way up. You can get out of general trial and get into a unit, make more money, reduce your caseload and dedicate more time to individual cases," he said. "There is still some incentive in that office to work your way up.

"In the PD's office, you just have to want to do it."

Advertise with us

In the public defender's office, there is only one specialized trial unit, and that's for homicides. Still, promotion to the unit results in no increased pay.

Mr. Sheets understands why there is a difference in the budgets between the PD's office and the DA's office.

"The public will understand paying the district attorney's office. They prosecute the bad guys. They wear the white hats," he said. "What public Joe wants to hear the defender's office is out there zealously representing their clients?"

But, he continued, "to say prosecution of cases is more important than the defense of cases is to question the entire American criminal justice system."