When the FBI reported last week that Pittsburgh, like the nation, saw crime drop for the fourth year in a row, Mayor Luke Ravenstahl was quick to proclaim that the city is experiencing "50-year historic crime lows."

He reiterated the statement before an anti-violence gathering at the City-County Building, saying the city continues to be among the nation's safest.

But, as is often the case with crime statistics, the figures can be deceiving.

The mayor drew his conclusion based on the totals for all serious crimes in 2010, provided by the FBI in its annual Uniform Crime Report. The report shows that Part I offenses -- homicide, rape, robbery, aggravated assault, burglary, theft, car theft and arson -- are down almost across the board.

Advertise with us

Deputy Police Chief Paul Donaldson, too, welcomed the news, saying Pittsburgh saw the lowest crime totals in 40 years.

The problem with crunching numbers and making sweeping statements about historic crime trends for Pittsburgh, more so than for many other metro areas, is that the city is about half the size it used to be.

So any drop in crime compared with decades ago has to be examined in light of a dramatic population decline.

Adjusting for that drop, then, the rate per 100,000 is generally worse now than it was 40 or 50 years ago, at least for crimes of violence that most people associate with safety, such as murder, robbery and assault.

In 1960, for example, the city had about 604,000 people but recorded only 28 murders. That works out to a murder rate of 4.6 per 100,000 people. By 1970, when the population had fallen to about 520,000, there were 63 murders, for a rate of about 12.1 per 100,000.

Advertise with us

But last year, with the city's population at about 312,000, there were 55 murders. The rate, then, was 17.6 per 100,000, substantially higher than in 1970.

Typically the city records between 50 and 60 homicides a year, but the number has not fallen with the population loss.

The robbery rate is also much higher than it was 50 years ago.

Although the rate per 100,000 last year was 381, down from 517 in 1970, the rate in 1960 was just 131 robberies per 100,000 people.

The aggravated assault rate is also higher now than it used to be. In 1960, the rate was just 87 per 100,000. In 1970, it had spiked to 317 per 100,000. Last year it stood at 480 per 100,000.

Advertise with us

Aggravated assault, however, presents a complex picture and might not be the best barometer of violent crime. Alfred Blumstein, a noted criminologist at Carnegie Mellon University, said it is a less reliable statistic than murder or robbery because the reporting standards have changed over the decades. For example, many domestic assaults are now included in the totals when in the old days most would not be, skewing the true rate.

It's true that the entire metro region, which includes Allegheny and all surrounding counties, does enjoy one of the lowest violent crime rates in the nation at 319 crimes per 100,000. By comparison, the Baltimore area, which has about the same number of people, has a rate more than twice that.

But the rate for the city of Pittsburgh itself is fairly high, at 898 per 100,000, placing it in the top third of cities with 250,000 or more people. While the city did better in that category than such comparably sized towns as Cincinnati, with 1,085 violent crimes per 100,000, or Oakland, Calif., with 1,529, its rate was worse than in many others, including Tampa (623), Anaheim (343) and even New Orleans (727), although the Big Easy recorded many more murders with 175.

The worst violent crime rate in the country belonged to Detroit, followed by St. Louis, Memphis, Oakland and Baltimore.

Calculating overall crime rates can be tricky because increases in some crimes are often offset by declines in others. Auto theft, for example, has consistently declined through the years as newer models with anti-theft technology replace older ones that were easier to steal.

Advertise with us

Neither the mayor nor Chief Donaldson responded to requests for further clarification about how they reached their conclusions about current crime trends. A spokeswoman for the mayor said he based his statement on per capita rates but did not elaborate.

In a previous interview, Chief Donaldson acknowledged that gun violence remains a problem in the city. That point was driven home again Monday morning, when city officers responded to two shootings within six minutes of each other in the Hill District and the North Side. The one in the Hill District turned out to be a homicide. Another man was shot to death in the Hill District the following day. Police on Wednesday said they had yet to determine a motive for either killing.

Chief Donaldson said police are trying to curb shootings with a number of methods, including "intelligence-led" policing in which officers direct resources to areas where they predict crime will occur.

Despite the shootings, the general crime trend is downward, and the drop here reflects a nationwide decline for the fourth straight year, despite the economic downturn. Property crimes also dropped, according to the FBI, for the eighth year in a row.

In addition, the rate per 100,000 for both kinds of crimes dropped compared with 2009. The violent crime rate was 403 offenses per 100,000, a 6.5 percent decrease from 2009, and the property crime rate was 2,941 offenses per 100,000, a 3.3 percent drop.

Advertise with us

Crime is now at the level where it was in the 1960s. And some cities have seen huge turnarounds since the 1990s.

This story was originally published with images that are no longer available.