The Civic Arena may be one last plea away from demolition.
U.S. District Judge David S. Cercone threw out a lawsuit Friday that sought to block the arena's destruction, ruling that he had no legal jurisdiction to force federal agencies to halt the work.
The decision, only days before a hearing was to be held on the lawsuit, prompted plaintiff Preservation Pittsburgh to ask Judge Cercone for an emergency injunction while it appeals the ruling to the Third U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals.
"It's been an uphill battle but we're going to continue," said Scott Leib, president of Preservation Pittsburgh. "We really believe strongly that 10 years from now, people are going to look back and wish we hadn't demolished the Civic Arena."
Barring an 11th-hour reprieve, the demolition could start by the end of next week, said Mary Conturo, executive director of the city-Allegheny County Sports & Exhibition Authority, the arena owner.
Ms. Conturo said the SEA's contractor should finish abatement work inside the arena within the next few days and then start peeling off portions of the Igloo's distinctive retractable roof to remove asbestos. That would mark the start of the demolition.
She said the SEA sees no reason to hold back at this point despite the expected appeal to the circuit court. "There's currently no order in place that prevents us from going forward," she said.
In his 17-page opinion, Judge Cercone rejected the arguments of Preservation Pittsburgh that redevelopment of the arena's Hill District site would require federal highway funds and therefore a federal review of the plan to demolish the historic building.
Since the SEA hasn't applied for the funds, the federal agencies don't have to conduct any review, he found. Preservation Pittsburgh "has failed to convince this Court that there is any federal involvement with the Civic Arena demolition and redevelopment project," the judge wrote.
He ordered the case dismissed and the file closed. A hearing on the case set for Tuesday is now moot.
The SEA and the Penguins, with the backing of Mayor Luke Ravenstahl and County Executive Dan Onorato, want to demolish the arena and redevelop its site. Preservation Pittsburgh is part of a coalition that wants to preserve and reuse the arena.
Despite Friday's bid for an emergency injunction, Rob Pfaffmann, the local architect who has spearheaded the movement to reuse the arena, acknowledged that the end could be at hand.
"I think we've run out of options," he said.
Mr. Pfaffmann got the news about the ruling while he was traveling through Columbus, Ind., a city known for architectural innovation and design. He said Pittsburgh would come to regret the decision to tear down the arena.
"This is going to be a seminal moment in architectural history in the city of Pittsburgh and I don't think a lot of people realize that yet," he said.
"We had the opportunity to do something special in Pittsburgh and we blew it."
Both he and Mr. Leib questioned the Penguins' ability to turn the 28-acre arena site into an enclave for housing, offices, and retail uses they are proposing, particularly given the state of the economy.
"When the Penguins talk about formative development being a Subway or a T.G.I. Friday's, we know we're in trouble," said Mr. Pfaffmann, referring to the retail space on Fifth Avenue at the Consol Energy Center the team is developing.
The Penguins, on the other hand, hailed Judge Cercone's decision. "It's yet another positive step in the development of the former Mellon Arena site," said Travis Williams, the Penguins' chief operating officer.
He said the team plans to hold community meetings on the proposed redevelopment late this year or in early 2012 and hopes to start looking for a developer within a few months
The proposed development involves far more than restaurants or retail, he said. The goal is to create a residential and office community with retail to support it. He said the team is pleased that it has been able to fill two-thirds of the retail space available at Consol Energy Center in the building's first year.
"That's pretty good for today's economy," he said.
Mr. Leib also took issue with Judge Cercone's ruling. He said that "all signs indicate that the SEA still intends to use federal funds" as part of the proposed redevelopment.
"We continue to believe that the SEA's actions are anticipatory demolition and will result in the denial of federal funds in the future," he said.
However, Ms. Conturo has stated that federal funding for the redevelopment "is nothing more than a possibility" and that the work could proceed without it.


Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.